Limerick Forum

Top Ten - Goalkeepers

(Oldest Posts First)

Who do you think are the top 10 Goalkeepers in the county....
1. Nicky Quaid
2. Brian Murray
3. Aaron Murphy
4. Dave McCarthy
5. Barry Hennessey
6. Eoin McNamara
7. Padraig Kennedy
8. Cian Hedderman
9. Ger Flynn
10. Jack Banks

mantalk (Limerick) - Posts: 107 - 06/11/2015 14:38:27    1804965

Link

I agree with you there mantalk, I'd probably put McCarthy ahead of Murphy just slightly.

Gavin94 (Limerick) - Posts: 77 - 06/11/2015 16:09:50    1804993

Link

this is a very good topic.it seems to be the one area where limerick have a lot of strength.i,d put ger Flynn at 4.another keeper I,ve been impressed with is ger butler(claughaun),seen him make great saves in the past few years in a team that struggles.cian o dwyer(monaleen)is another who deserves a mention.

CTGAA10 (Limerick) - Posts: 1235 - 06/11/2015 16:34:18    1805001

Link

Darragh Stapleton from doon I think is good enough to make top 10

Southwest (Limerick) - Posts: 49 - 06/11/2015 17:42:46    1805012

Link

Aaron Murphy was badly treated in last years championship Quaid is No 1 Murphy No 2

treaty1973 (Limerick) - Posts: 93 - 06/11/2015 17:43:01    1805013

Link

Your top 10 is probably correct but I'd have it in a totally different order. Particularly the 1st 6.

mike03 (Limerick) - Posts: 2000 - 06/11/2015 18:03:52    1805018

Link

1. Brian Murray
2. Nicky Quaid
3. Dave McCarthy
4. Eoin McNamara
5. Barry Hennessey
6. Aaron Murphy
7. Shane O Donughue
8. Ger Flynn
9. Tommy Quaid
10. Jonathan Hayes
Great forum I mentioned it few years back top goalies around, cant comment on Jack Banks havent seen him, Hedderman ok only, Tommy Quaid was very good for CIT and Emmetts when in goals solid. Darragh Spaleton last years 21s goalie did ok but was poor in fitzgibbon final. I like Diarmuid Quirke of Hospital solid goalie should get call for minors. Top six not much between them all could easily be in goals. Donughue impressive for Adare PJ Hall good back up. Hayes of Ahane solid again. Podge Kennedy dose well for NaPiarsaigh unlucky not to makwe top ten. Murray number 1 but Quaid hasnt made any mistakes Hennessy top notch too Im a big McNanamra fan. McCarthy is the form goalie going by the 21s crucial against Tipp and Galway. Aaron Murphy long puck champion solid again.

cland (Limerick) - Posts: 229 - 06/11/2015 18:15:36    1805020

Link

1. Brian Murray
2. Nicky Quaid
3. Dave McCarthy
4. Eoin McNamara
5. Barry Hennessey
6. Aaron Murphy
7. Shane O Donughue
8. Ger Flynn
9. Tommy Quaid
10. Jonathan Hayes
Great forum I mentioned it few years back top goalies around, cant comment on Jack Banks havent seen him, Hedderman ok only, Tommy Quaid was very good for CIT and Emmetts when in goals solid. Darragh Spaleton last years 21s goalie did ok but was poor in fitzgibbon final. I like Diarmuid Quirke of Hospital solid goalie should get call for minors. Top six not much between them all could easily be in goals. Donughue impressive for Adare PJ Hall good back up. Hayes of Ahane solid again. Podge Kennedy dose well for NaPiarsaigh unlucky not to makwe top ten. Murray number 1 but Quaid hasnt made any mistakes Hennessy top notch too Im a big McNanamra fan. McCarthy is the form goalie going by the 21s crucial against Tipp and Galway. Aaron Murphy long puck champion solid again.

cland (Limerick) - Posts: 229 - 06/11/2015 18:26:29    1805023

Link

Guy id like to see in with the Limerick Intermediates is Ciaran Malachy Ryan has put couple of great years with Pallasgreen great goalkeeper very good puck outs and decent shot stopper.

cland (Limerick) - Posts: 229 - 07/11/2015 10:18:41    1805102

Link

Agree With you cland, had a very good year last year along with his brother Colin. Got motm in co final last year thought he was outstanding. Surprised he didn't get a run with limerick

Southwest (Limerick) - Posts: 49 - 07/11/2015 17:12:54    1805174

Link