|
Replying To iarmhiabu: "The only well McHugh should be going to is the Well in Moate. Moate have taken this Championship by storm, sweeping all before them to reach the Semi Final. On this kind of form they will dethrone The Downs and I would imagine they have the resources to improve the County squad." Maybe Shane Lowry.
jacktheboy (Donegal) - Posts: 550 - 17/09/2026 16:07:16
2694127
Link
0
|
|
Replying To TheWagonWheel-N91Y529: "Wing backs from Kgad Gahan and Cole
Buckley and Masterson Shamrocks
Gavigan - Malachys
Slevin, Connell, 2 kellehers, and Moody - Tubberclair
Leech - Killucan
Mulvihill - Gcastle
Scully - Shan
Mitchell and Moran - Downs
Think we will see a good few of 20s make league match day panels, watched the minor semi-final and Scahill will 100% play Westmeath senior football before playing club senior football with Shan" It would be interesting to see some of those names in. I guess the thing would be to integrate them in an O Byrne Cup otherwise it's hard to see them get the exposure to make an impact.
DelaneyCup2026 (Westmeath) - Posts: 56 - 17/09/2026 16:17:45
2694130
Link
0
|
|
Will Scahill Shandonagh will also be involved. LC student and on CM team plus 20s but prodigious talent if nurtured properly. In a ten minute spell other night he destroyed Kinnegad in minor semi final.
Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2800 - 17/09/2026 16:32:19
2694131
Link
0
|
|
Replying To martyW: "If a Junior team cant beat a senior second team they'll struggle badly in Intermediate, similar in Junior 2. Removing 2nd teams wont improve the standards of Junior teams going forward. Only Mullingar and Garrycastle have won it in the past 20 years" To some extent I agree but and it is a big but. Most of the stand alone Junior clubs are in their position due to the following reasons; Numbers-Most of them have a ten year period where they will thrive or perhaps for a bit longer however when the numbers dry up as with Bunbrosna now, they drop sharply and very rapidly. Geography; Majority of them are either close to a county boundary or hemmed in by other clubs with greater catchment areas. St Pauls will always be hemmed in by the Meath border as St Josephs with Offaly and Bunbrosna and Ballynacargy with Longford. Delvin with Meath and of course Hurling is the main draw there while Loughnavally are also badly squeezed in by a number of clubs. Kilbeggan are a bit of an enigma in that they have a reasonable population to draw from but they are gone into a yo yo between Junior and Intermediate. 20 years ago they were similar but it was between Senior & Intermediate at the time. Ballycomoyle the most hemmed in of all being wedged into a portion of Westmeath bounded by Cavan & Meath. The fear I have is that four of five of those clubs will not exist in ten years time. The same has happened in Longford in recent years where Junior clubs have disappeared or been absorbed. I dont have a crystal ball but if any of the eight sole clubs graded as Junior are to manage long term, then they may well be as amalgamated units in some shape or form.
Greengrass1 (Westmeath) - Posts: 98 - 17/09/2026 18:20:36
2694139
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Greengrass1: "To some extent I agree but and it is a big but. Most of the stand alone Junior clubs are in their position due to the following reasons; Numbers-Most of them have a ten year period where they will thrive or perhaps for a bit longer however when the numbers dry up as with Bunbrosna now, they drop sharply and very rapidly. Geography; Majority of them are either close to a county boundary or hemmed in by other clubs with greater catchment areas. St Pauls will always be hemmed in by the Meath border as St Josephs with Offaly and Bunbrosna and Ballynacargy with Longford. Delvin with Meath and of course Hurling is the main draw there while Loughnavally are also badly squeezed in by a number of clubs. Kilbeggan are a bit of an enigma in that they have a reasonable population to draw from but they are gone into a yo yo between Junior and Intermediate. 20 years ago they were similar but it was between Senior & Intermediate at the time. Ballycomoyle the most hemmed in of all being wedged into a portion of Westmeath bounded by Cavan & Meath. The fear I have is that four of five of those clubs will not exist in ten years time. The same has happened in Longford in recent years where Junior clubs have disappeared or been absorbed. I dont have a crystal ball but if any of the eight sole clubs graded as Junior are to manage long term, then they may well be as amalgamated units in some shape or form." Fair points and it's not just at that level. There are some intermediate clubs struggling results wise and numbers wise. It's not easy for clubs and especially older members to countenance the idea of joining forces permanently especially with neighbours who are traditionally their greatest rivals.
Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2800 - 17/09/2026 20:01:09
2694144
Link
0
|
|
Could we eventually see a delvin St Paul's and Ballycomoyle CFCW amalgamation at adult level also?
westmeathgaa11 (Westmeath) - Posts: 379 - 17/09/2026 20:45:32
2694147
Link
0
|
|
Replying To TheWagonWheel-N91Y529: "Wing backs from Kgad Gahan and Cole
Buckley and Masterson Shamrocks
Gavigan - Malachys
Slevin, Connell, 2 kellehers, and Moody - Tubberclair
Leech - Killucan
Mulvihill - Gcastle
Scully - Shan
Mitchell and Moran - Downs
Think we will see a good few of 20s make league match day panels, watched the minor semi-final and Scahill will 100% play Westmeath senior football before playing club senior football with Shan" He was in the stands for the Moate and Athlone game anyways, although some people were saying he was also in looking at Reilly and McCabe in the match before hand. Would be a blow to the hurlers if they were to switch codes
WestmeathGael1 (Westmeath) - Posts: 9 - 18/09/2026 08:56:02
2694163
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Greengrass1: "To some extent I agree but and it is a big but. Most of the stand alone Junior clubs are in their position due to the following reasons; Numbers-Most of them have a ten year period where they will thrive or perhaps for a bit longer however when the numbers dry up as with Bunbrosna now, they drop sharply and very rapidly. Geography; Majority of them are either close to a county boundary or hemmed in by other clubs with greater catchment areas. St Pauls will always be hemmed in by the Meath border as St Josephs with Offaly and Bunbrosna and Ballynacargy with Longford. Delvin with Meath and of course Hurling is the main draw there while Loughnavally are also badly squeezed in by a number of clubs. Kilbeggan are a bit of an enigma in that they have a reasonable population to draw from but they are gone into a yo yo between Junior and Intermediate. 20 years ago they were similar but it was between Senior & Intermediate at the time. Ballycomoyle the most hemmed in of all being wedged into a portion of Westmeath bounded by Cavan & Meath. The fear I have is that four of five of those clubs will not exist in ten years time. The same has happened in Longford in recent years where Junior clubs have disappeared or been absorbed. I dont have a crystal ball but if any of the eight sole clubs graded as Junior are to manage long term, then they may well be as amalgamated units in some shape or form." Which 4 or 5 current Junior clubs will not exist in ten years time do you think?
Darragh (Westmeath) - Posts: 377 - 18/09/2026 09:01:14
2694164
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Greengrass1: "To some extent I agree but and it is a big but. Most of the stand alone Junior clubs are in their position due to the following reasons; Numbers-Most of them have a ten year period where they will thrive or perhaps for a bit longer however when the numbers dry up as with Bunbrosna now, they drop sharply and very rapidly. Geography; Majority of them are either close to a county boundary or hemmed in by other clubs with greater catchment areas. St Pauls will always be hemmed in by the Meath border as St Josephs with Offaly and Bunbrosna and Ballynacargy with Longford. Delvin with Meath and of course Hurling is the main draw there while Loughnavally are also badly squeezed in by a number of clubs. Kilbeggan are a bit of an enigma in that they have a reasonable population to draw from but they are gone into a yo yo between Junior and Intermediate. 20 years ago they were similar but it was between Senior & Intermediate at the time. Ballycomoyle the most hemmed in of all being wedged into a portion of Westmeath bounded by Cavan & Meath. The fear I have is that four of five of those clubs will not exist in ten years time. The same has happened in Longford in recent years where Junior clubs have disappeared or been absorbed. I dont have a crystal ball but if any of the eight sole clubs graded as Junior are to manage long term, then they may well be as amalgamated units in some shape or form." Some of these Junior clubs must face reality, they have to amalgamate, pride will stop them in most cases, Ballynacargy and Bunbrosna are a prme example of an amalgamation that makes sense, they are already amalgamated at underage level. They havent got the numbers to make an impact at Junior level currently, if they have any ambition of moving up the ladder they must consider joining together...
dec (None) - Posts: 320 - 18/09/2026 10:15:25
2694170
Link
0
|
|
The demographics document published by the GAA last year basically shows this is inevitable. Clubs are going to go. 3 clubs went in Longford , one was bordered with Westmeath and many of them ended up in Milltown. Another swallowed up by greed with the town and another amalgamated with a bigger club and they've been going ok since. The worrying thing about those other two clubs going is that it happened without much intervention or support. Westmeath gaa is duty bound to give these clubs any support they need and help them to stay alive
Paidi04 (Westmeath) - Posts: 29 - 18/09/2026 10:54:09
2694174
Link
0
|