HoganStand GAA Football and Hurling

National Forum

Limerick Junior Hurling Championship 2017

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

You need to Login to Post

Replying To theinsiderlimer: "Heard that Doon won their appeal last night. So its Doon/Caherline East Final. East board were 100% wrong so I'm told and was only a delaying tactic for the East final" Delaying tactic for what exactly? MunsterChampion (Limerick) - Posts: 84 - 15/09/2017 00:10:41 2046129 Link
Replying To MunsterChampion: "Delaying tactic for what exactly?" If East final went ahead as planned I'm told Caherline would have been without 4 key players theinsiderlimer (Limerick) - Posts: 38 - 15/09/2017 09:46:07 2046154 Link
Easy win for Kilmallock in South final. Have to be one of the favourites! When is East final fixed? WestLimerickBog (Limerick) - Posts: 43 - 18/09/2017 01:32:43 2047182 Link
Accordidng to fixtures its fixed for the 24th but minor B co semi is fixed for same date so one will have to be moved theinsiderlimer (Limerick) - Posts: 38 - 18/09/2017 09:15:38 2047237 Link
Replying To bestisbest: "Amazing doon weren't thrown out of the competition, seems the video showed them bringing on a player after the altercation occurred" What rubbish are you talking ? have you seen the video? clearly shows substitution has been made and that the player was on the sideline when he received his second yellow. anotheryear (Limerick) - Posts: 51 - 18/09/2017 09:48:05 2047262 Link
Replying To anotheryear: "What rubbish are you talking ? have you seen the video? clearly shows substitution has been made and that the player was on the sideline when he received his second yellow." How was he sent off for an "altercation after he was taken off" could you explain to me? He was sent off on the field of play which the umpire saw but was taken off before the ref spoke to the umpire bestisbest (Limerick) - Posts: 206 - 18/09/2017 12:15:02 2047385 Link
Replying To bestisbest: "How was he sent off for an "altercation after he was taken off" could you explain to me? He was sent off on the field of play which the umpire saw but was taken off before the ref spoke to the umpire" if you have seen the video then you know all the answers! But IMO and that of the county board he was already substituted. Is it correct to say that Ballybricken didn't even appeal in the first place and that on the night of the hearing they, hence, had no status when the county board overruled them? anotheryear (Limerick) - Posts: 51 - 18/09/2017 16:18:23 2047566 Link
East board are very much in the wrong here. Seems that they wanted the junior east final played after county senior quarter final in the hope that doon would lose more junior players to senior.the whole thing was a farce. County board immediately struck out their case. DurkaDurka (Limerick) - Posts: 63 - 18/09/2017 18:07:05 2047619 Link
Replying To anotheryear: "if you have seen the video then you know all the answers! But IMO and that of the county board he was already substituted. Is it correct to say that Ballybricken didn't even appeal in the first place and that on the night of the hearing they, hence, had no status when the county board overruled them?" Just in the last few days I saw the video and it looked like there was an incident involving a doon player already on a yellow card and they coincidentally were very quick to substitute him. The docket for the sub wasn't in the refs hand until after the second yellow was given so in that instance alone the sub isn't made if I'm right bestisbest (Limerick) - Posts: 206 - 18/09/2017 18:25:28 2047623 Link
Replying To bestisbest: "Just in the last few days I saw the video and it looked like there was an incident involving a doon player already on a yellow card and they coincidentally were very quick to substitute him. The docket for the sub wasn't in the refs hand until after the second yellow was given so in that instance alone the sub isn't made if I'm right" I'd say you would serve your time best trying to promote hurling in your club instead of cribbing about a loss and digging deep to try and find any kind of technicality that would keep Ballybricken in the competition. Pathetic sidelineview08 (Limerick) - Posts: 75 - 18/09/2017 21:14:39 2047714 Link
caherline v doon sunday in cappamore who'll win it? Limcofinest (Limerick) - Posts: 83 - 19/09/2017 00:42:53 2047853 Link
Replying To MunsterChampion: "Delaying tactic for what exactly?" doon and ballyb delayed to assist caherline who were missing players, givme a f##kin break Limcofinest (Limerick) - Posts: 83 - 19/09/2017 00:44:18 2047854 Link
Anyone have any thoughts on West final next Sunday? WestLimerickBog (Limerick) - Posts: 43 - 19/09/2017 03:52:18 2047876 Link
Replying To sidelineview08: "I'd say you would serve your time best trying to promote hurling in your club instead of cribbing about a loss and digging deep to try and find any kind of technicality that would keep Ballybricken in the competition. Pathetic" Cribbing with good reason, anyone who has seen the video will know what I'm talking about. Doon will go nowhere in this competition as soon as there's a decent referee in the county stages those tactics won't be of any help to them bestisbest (Limerick) - Posts: 206 - 19/09/2017 09:06:40 2047897 Link
Replying To bestisbest: "Just in the last few days I saw the video and it looked like there was an incident involving a doon player already on a yellow card and they coincidentally were very quick to substitute him. The docket for the sub wasn't in the refs hand until after the second yellow was given so in that instance alone the sub isn't made if I'm right" correct to say quick to sub him after he received his first yellow.... it had absolutely nothing to do with a 2nd yellow ( how could it since he only received it after been substituted). IF, as you say, the substitution was made after the sending off then this reflects poorly on the ref and why would Doon do something as foolish as to try replace a player sent off 9 mins into injury time when they were cruising to victory comfortably? anotheryear (Limerick) - Posts: 51 - 19/09/2017 10:03:57 2047920 Link
Replying To bestisbest: "Cribbing with good reason, anyone who has seen the video will know what I'm talking about. Doon will go nowhere in this competition as soon as there's a decent referee in the county stages those tactics won't be of any help to them" my god you are been very harsh on the ref now..... is that why you lost the game so ? #blameeveryoneexceptyourself anotheryear (Limerick) - Posts: 51 - 19/09/2017 10:17:27 2047926 Link
Replying To anotheryear: "my god you are been very harsh on the ref now..... is that why you lost the game so ? #blameeveryoneexceptyourself" well I watched the video and there was exactly 5 minutes of play after the red card with doon 5 points ahead when ye should have been a man down I wouldn't exactly say "cruising to victory" bestisbest (Limerick) - Posts: 206 - 19/09/2017 10:54:21 2047943 Link
Doon were 6 points up when the incident happened, 3 minutes 30 seconds left to play if you watch video correctly and no score for remainder of match. Doon were much the better team and the sub slip can clearly be seen given to ref before the sending off so if you want to get technical, the sub was made. The sub slip that is being referred to was Doon's 5th and final sub with that player clearly seen leaving the field of play. It's all pathetic, Doon won fair & square, time to move on. hurler90 (Limerick) - Posts: 185 - 19/09/2017 11:27:20 2047961 Link
Replying To hurler90: "Doon were 6 points up when the incident happened, 3 minutes 30 seconds left to play if you watch video correctly and no score for remainder of match. Doon were much the better team and the sub slip can clearly be seen given to ref before the sending off so if you want to get technical, the sub was made. The sub slip that is being referred to was Doon's 5th and final sub with that player clearly seen leaving the field of play. It's all pathetic, Doon won fair & square, time to move on." What video were you watching?? If you want to be technical about everything I said is correct, but anyway it's over and doon have got away with it. And the only thing that's pathetic about this ordeal is blaming caherline saying it was a delaying tactic bestisbest (Limerick) - Posts: 206 - 19/09/2017 12:00:04 2047993 Link
Any thought on West final on this weekend? WestLimerickBog (Limerick) - Posts: 43 - 19/09/2017 13:03:44 2048041 Link