National Forum

Club Championships 2017

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To 890202:  "Predictions for the weekend -
Gorey v st Martins - ill go for a st martins win but i think they arent going that great. Gorey probably just not good enough
Rapps v Oulart - Oulart are a team that is fading and the Rapps have been very impressive. If they can keep Garret Sinnott quiet then ill go for them

St Annes v Bunclody - St Annes won this fixture when they played in the league stages but i think bunclody are going better now and i expect them to win

Duffry v Fethard - Both of these teams are better than 3/4 of the teams in the higher grade but i think the duffry will win this one. They have been going very well, i suppose fethard have aswell but ill just about give the duffry the nod.

Junior B semi-final - Adamstown v Oylegate - Adamstown seem to get this far every year but cant seem to progress any further, and i think the same will happen again. Oylegate for me."
Gorey v Rapps final would be great.. Unlikely to happen though

Groundball (Wexford) - Posts: 122 - 06/10/2017 11:32:33    2053524

Link

I am going for an Oulart Martins final, I think they will have too much for the 2 town teams unfortunately as it would be a huge boost for hurling in the 2 towns.
Good day for it, hope a big crowd heading in to it. Cant expect much better in October!

Pinkie (Wexford) - Posts: 4100 - 08/10/2017 12:42:45    2053847

Link

Fethard were deserving winners yesterday. Duffry will be disappointed with their performance but Fethard were dominant for the most part and probably could have won by more than the final scoreline. Duffry got very little from open play but they rallied well after going down to 14 men and it was a right in the melting pot until Fethard worked some good scores at the end. Fethard have some excellent hurlers and they'll be a handful for any team in intermediate next year.

Dirk (Wexford) - Posts: 65 - 08/10/2017 13:12:03    2053851

Link

As a neutral, having seen about 20 senior hurling games this year it has become clear to me that the standard of referring is very poor. There are lads getting senior games who are terrible referees. James Owens, Niall McDonald, John Carton and Justin Heffernan are the 4 best and after that the other senior referees are either too old or too useless. Today's second game was very poor in terms of refereeing and the first two quarter finals a fortnight ago were also poor. Whatever criteria is being used to select referees for senior hurling games needs to be changed as soon as possible. And the refereeing performance in the St Martins v Shels football game last week was the worst display I've ever seen from a referee on an intercounty refereeing panel.

In relation to the hurling itself the best way to describe both St Martins and Oulart is functional. Not spectacular. Gorey had a chance for a lot of the game but the two goals really came at perfect times for st martins. Gorey were impressive and worked very hard but the better team won. The second game I believe the rapps had every chance to win but just didn't take them. Des Mythen was given too much space and Liam Ryan should have been put on Garret Sinnott. Other than those two tactical errors I believe the Rapps are every bit as good a team as oulart, but experience showed in the end. Oulart will definitely be more happy with the refereeing than the Rapps.

I expect oulart to win the final. I don't think the Martins have the required battling qualities when push comes to shove.

890202 (Wexford) - Posts: 1278 - 08/10/2017 18:55:07    2053891

Link

First post, only discovered this forum recently and held off on posting until now. Was in Wexford park today and thought there were a lot of good hurlers on display. For Gorey the Doyles and Jack Cullen were impressive in my view, while Rory O Connor was the martins main man with Willie Devereux hurling an excellent game also. Mark Maloney was also quite good I believe. Not surprised to see the Martin's win. They have the talent needed to be successful but they can't seem to get on a run and pull away from teams which means they are always likely to be dragged into tight games. The second game was good as well, particularly in the second half when it began to get close. For oulart, Keith rossitter, Kevin Sheridan, des mythen and rory Jacob were the standouts in my opinion while Sinnott caught a few balls and caused a bit of trouble in the first half. For the Rapps I believe they are one of the nicest teams to watch. Ricky Fox hurled a lot of ball but he also gave mythen a lot of space. Jack Kelly and James Peare were outstanding all year and Kelly in particular was Brilliant again today. Kevin Foley hurled very well as usual while up front Liam Ryan broke up a lot of play and won balls for others around him. Ryan Mahan was good as was Darragh Pepper despite a slow start. He probably should have been awarded a penalty too. Looking forward to see if they can build on this next year

I wouldn't be surprised if the final was a draw!!!

And about the standard of refereeing I largely agree with the post above. It has been poor at times particularly in the second game today and in previous rounds too. Hard to know how to improve it other than just pick 6 referees and only give senior games to them rather than the 10/12 lads that currently get them.

Onfor15 (Wexford) - Posts: 524 - 08/10/2017 19:56:31    2053918

Link

Was at 2 games today, expected winners prevailed after both opposing teams didn't have a cut or belief if you ask me.

On another note. Desperately saddened to hear of the death of Willie Sunderland before throw in in the Oulart game today. A fantastic hurling man who'll be sorely missed. One of the most passionate hurling men I ever came across.

My thoughts are with his family and may he rest in peace.

dbyrney1 (Wexford) - Posts: 74 - 08/10/2017 20:00:58    2053920

Link

Was at 2 games today, expected winners prevailed after both opposing teams didn't have a cut or belief if you ask me.

On another note. Desperately saddened to hear of the death of Willie Sunderland before throw in in the Oulart game today. A fantastic hurling man who'll be sorely missed. One of the most passionate hurling men I ever came across.

My thoughts are with his family and may he rest in peace.

dbyrney1 (Wexford) - Posts: 74 - 08/10/2017 20:06:19    2053923

Link

As expected all year, Oulart Martins final.
I thought the Rapps believed they could beat Oulart, they just lacked that bit of experience. It was Oularts seasoned men who got them over the line, along with Kevin Sheridan who was fantastic I thought.
The chasing pack are getting close, and will overtake in the next few years as they are aging. It is a long time since we had so many good young hurlers, and more coming through.
A point worth noting here which I heard in WP today. If Mick Jacob wins a county title, he will overtake Fr. Martin Caseys 12 county title medal haul, and equal John Quigley's record of winning a county medal 20 years after he won his first in 1997. It would be fittig to a player and family have given so much to club and county.
I expect Naomh Eanna and Rapps to be back, Gorey are doing so much right having won lots at underage in recent times.
I still think Oularts experience and guile, and the fact that St. Martins might have to play 2 football matches before it, will be the difference and I expect them to retain the Bowe cup in 3 weeks time.

Pinkie (Wexford) - Posts: 4100 - 08/10/2017 20:42:30    2053932

Link

Was in Wexford Park also today,I would disagree with some of the posters above, I thought the first game was very poor, zero life in it, always felt Martins were going to win, I thought Gorey were very poor apart from a few highlights during the game and Oylegate must be disappointed looking at them today. Refereeing was extremely poor in first game, in fairness Conor McDonald was held pulled any everything else and not given a free. The second game was a much better standard and the play seemed to flow a lot better. Rapps will be kicking themselves looking back, when they were only 1 point down, Liam Ryan had a glorious chance and instead of picking it up pulled it across the goal with the resulting forward missing and then having a chance himself a few minutes later. But it seems to be the same storey every day with Oulart, teams have chances but just can't finish them. The referee in the second game nearly made a shocking decision, giving a point when he had blown his whistle and the Rapps players stopping, only for a Rapps selector to come on and make him change his mind.

Overall I expect Oulart to win the final as they will have that extra week break which should stand to them.

alwaysasub (Wexford) - Posts: 403 - 08/10/2017 20:44:01    2053933

Link

Rumours of Oularts demise were greatly exaggerated. When you think about it, there's a perception that because Jacob, Rossiter and Sinnott retired from inter-county, that they are old team. They aren't really though. Plenty left in the tank based on today's performance. Sprayed the ball around with ease.

I felt Gorey shot themselves in the foot. Their backs to a man where generally on top, particularly Eoin Molloy and Jack Cullen, but they did not supply enough ball into Mac et all. Positioning Conroy at corner forward was a strange move as well. He didn't get a feel of the ball at all. Martin's were far more efficient up front and picked off more scores from play. Their first goal should have been cleared twice by Gorey in the build-up, but fair dues to Rory O'Connor. He has shown maturity and leadership beyond his years. Outstanding talent.

I expect Oulart to dismantle them in the final though. Their game management is far above anyone else in the county.

beano (Wexford) - Posts: 1424 - 08/10/2017 21:04:14    2053939

Link

Replying To beano:  "Rumours of Oularts demise were greatly exaggerated. When you think about it, there's a perception that because Jacob, Rossiter and Sinnott retired from inter-county, that they are old team. They aren't really though. Plenty left in the tank based on today's performance. Sprayed the ball around with ease.

I felt Gorey shot themselves in the foot. Their backs to a man where generally on top, particularly Eoin Molloy and Jack Cullen, but they did not supply enough ball into Mac et all. Positioning Conroy at corner forward was a strange move as well. He didn't get a feel of the ball at all. Martin's were far more efficient up front and picked off more scores from play. Their first goal should have been cleared twice by Gorey in the build-up, but fair dues to Rory O'Connor. He has shown maturity and leadership beyond his years. Outstanding talent.

I expect Oulart to dismantle them in the final though. Their game management is far above anyone else in the county."
I think dismantle might be pushing it a bit

freshoh (Wexford) - Posts: 131 - 08/10/2017 21:27:58    2053944

Link

Replying To freshoh:  "I think dismantle might be pushing it a bit"
i think dismantle they will not,but if martins win the football replay,i think it could cost them a glorious chance to win the hurling.

perfect10 (Wexford) - Posts: 3929 - 09/10/2017 10:19:22    2054015

Link

Replying To perfect10:  "i think dismantle they will not,but if martins win the football replay,i think it could cost them a glorious chance to win the hurling."
if St Martins win the football replay it will give them a chance to win four championships in one year with top team in their club.

Intermediate Ladies football WON, Senior Camogie WON, Senior Football (Semi Final Replay), Senior Hurling (Into Final).

I don't agree with the bull comments that being in one will cost them over the other. St Martin's are a club embracing every person in their club. They are aiming for the stars and they are reaching them. Their underage success speaks for itself and while it does not guarantee success they are doing something right. Not only are they performing locally but they are now feeding Wexford with players in all codes also.

Personally I would love to see them win both hurling and football. I think I am right in saying they are in an elite group with Shelmaliers now by having a senior team in Hurling, Football, Ladies Football and Camogie.

hurlorhurley (Wexford) - Posts: 1660 - 09/10/2017 10:48:00    2054029

Link

hurlorhurley,can you show me where i said i dont want them to win both?your just looking to pick a fight,and as a dual supporter i think i can say that it is great that they embrace both.
do i believe they will win both?i think they are more likely to win the football.do i think they will win either?no,i dont.
there was no need to open up a dual debate over a throw-away comment.

perfect10 (Wexford) - Posts: 3929 - 09/10/2017 11:06:38    2054036

Link

Replying To perfect10:  "hurlorhurley,can you show me where i said i dont want them to win both?your just looking to pick a fight,and as a dual supporter i think i can say that it is great that they embrace both.
do i believe they will win both?i think they are more likely to win the football.do i think they will win either?no,i dont.
there was no need to open up a dual debate over a throw-away comment."
How does winning the football replay cost them a glorious chance of winning the hurling? Surely the momentum would be right behind them, they would be on a high, wouldn't losing the football and being down in the dumps over that not be worse than winning the football semi-final????????

hurlorhurley (Wexford) - Posts: 1660 - 09/10/2017 12:11:15    2054073

Link

Replying To hurlorhurley:  "How does winning the football replay cost them a glorious chance of winning the hurling? Surely the momentum would be right behind them, they would be on a high, wouldn't losing the football and being down in the dumps over that not be worse than winning the football semi-final????????"
did you ever hear of a condition called fatigue?it is often caused by playing on heavy pitches,etc?
meanwhile,oulart will have 2 weekends off.
oh and by the way,i get a lot of after match reaction in my work near the park and both teams and supporters last weekend wanted a winner and a loser for that very reason.so it is not just my opinion,both teams felt they would have less chance of winning both due to the replay.
jesus,say anything on here which can be jumped on as anti football,and you get your head bitten off even when it is not meant such a way at all!

perfect10 (Wexford) - Posts: 3929 - 09/10/2017 12:22:05    2054079

Link

Replying To perfect10:  "did you ever hear of a condition called fatigue?it is often caused by playing on heavy pitches,etc?
meanwhile,oulart will have 2 weekends off.
oh and by the way,i get a lot of after match reaction in my work near the park and both teams and supporters last weekend wanted a winner and a loser for that very reason.so it is not just my opinion,both teams felt they would have less chance of winning both due to the replay.
jesus,say anything on here which can be jumped on as anti football,and you get your head bitten off even when it is not meant such a way at all!"
Isnt the hurling final on first?
Therefore they win on Sunday and then play the hurling the weekend after?

hurlorhurley (Wexford) - Posts: 1660 - 09/10/2017 12:36:43    2054084

Link

Replying To perfect10:  "did you ever hear of a condition called fatigue?it is often caused by playing on heavy pitches,etc?
meanwhile,oulart will have 2 weekends off.
oh and by the way,i get a lot of after match reaction in my work near the park and both teams and supporters last weekend wanted a winner and a loser for that very reason.so it is not just my opinion,both teams felt they would have less chance of winning both due to the replay.
jesus,say anything on here which can be jumped on as anti football,and you get your head bitten off even when it is not meant such a way at all!"
So if they lose the football semi they wont be fatigued for the hurling the following weekend?? I think you may have just phrased it wrong but either way they will be playing a match week before hurling final now.
I do agree with those who say momentum is a key factor though. From my own experience a loss in one code a week before the other could have negative effect. Winning breeds winning afterall.

hurlin101 (Wexford) - Posts: 104 - 09/10/2017 12:48:55    2054091

Link

Replying To hurlin101:  "So if they lose the football semi they wont be fatigued for the hurling the following weekend?? I think you may have just phrased it wrong but either way they will be playing a match week before hurling final now.
I do agree with those who say momentum is a key factor though. From my own experience a loss in one code a week before the other could have negative effect. Winning breeds winning afterall."
If St Martins lost in the football could there be a chance of a Senior County Final Double header????

hurlorhurley (Wexford) - Posts: 1660 - 09/10/2017 13:06:45    2054104

Link

Replying To hurlorhurley:  "If St Martins lost in the football could there be a chance of a Senior County Final Double header????"
It's a lovely idea, but I can't see the " money" people going for it. Some people are more interested in €€€€€€'s than in accommodating players or spectators.

On the fixtures or fatigue issue, if St Martins keep on winning in both codes, there's the possibility of them playing several weeks in succession. The county finals will only be finished in time to straight into Leinster club championship. I don't have dates or fixtures, but the Leinster football ( club) usually starts on the October bank holiday weekend, which will only be a week after county final.

yelowbelly (Wexford) - Posts: 409 - 09/10/2017 13:38:45    2054117

Link