National Forum

Club Championships 2017

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To Wicklowman:  "Who do people fancy between Kilanerin and Rosslare?"
Kilanerin should win. Rosslare have been admirable in returning back among the contenders after a few fallow years, but Kilanerin look a different animal with the additions from the Rock strengthening the XV.

But I feel should HWH come through the other semi, that they may well shock Kilanerin yet. Some class footballers that will only relish knocking Kilanerin down a peg or two. Then again, Ferns will be in a similar boat in the semi. Could be a great game.

beano (Wexford) - Posts: 1424 - 29/09/2017 18:57:13    2051782

Link

Replying To beano:  "Kilanerin should win. Rosslare have been admirable in returning back among the contenders after a few fallow years, but Kilanerin look a different animal with the additions from the Rock strengthening the XV.

But I feel should HWH come through the other semi, that they may well shock Kilanerin yet. Some class footballers that will only relish knocking Kilanerin down a peg or two. Then again, Ferns will be in a similar boat in the semi. Could be a great game."
first time seeing starlights today, very impressed, they played good intelligent football, they are very well coached, id give them a great chance in final, shels might have missed their chance, but maybe that game will bring them on so u never know

Stmunnsriver (Wexford) - Posts: 2845 - 01/10/2017 19:06:13    2052159

Link

Didnt get to see the first match yesterday but was impressed with the Shelmaliers defensively. At times they6 only had one man at the other end of the pitch but it worked well as they had players to break quick up the pitch. The problem with this is you need to be super fit and I felt Shels ran out of steam in the last 10. I do feel Martins wont be caught cold again and I think Shels opportunity has passed.

Kilanerin won in impressive fashion. I feel the joining together with Tara Rocks has benefited them more than Tara Rocks as there is a very good chance they will be senior next year and if so, they will be senior football and Intermediate A hurling. I'm sure they will be more likely to concentrate on Senior football rather than hurling next year so where that leaves Tara Rocks hurlers is unknown. I believe also alot of players have left them during the year so they might not be able to field a team even if they decided to go back on there own.

Ballymurn won the Intermediate A as expected, although by all accounts this is one Gorey will have left behind them.

Bit if a surprise in the Junior Football with St. Martins winning, not sure what Rathgarogue/Cushinstown have to do to win it. I'm sure they will regroup and go again next year as they have been in numerous semi finals and finals over the last few years.

alwaysasub (Wexford) - Posts: 403 - 02/10/2017 09:26:49    2052281

Link

I must doff my cap and say fair dues to Starlights. Obviously Castletown are my club so I would back them to the hilt, but I was impressed by their game management yesterday. Now, Castletown should have had 8-9 points on the board rather than the five they scored by half-time as a two point gap was never going to be enough.

Starlights manfully stuck to their convictions and had faith in their system which was the polar opposite to Castletown, who seemed to retreat into their shell to defend what was a flimsy lead.

I will say though that Danny Gardiner was wasted at full-back. They could have dropped someone back there to mind Furlong and allowed Danny to flourish around the middle. Nick Doyle ruled the roost there and it was poor in-game management not to curb his influence earlier. Gardiner was the hub to most of Castletown's attacks with his running, so should have beem utilised better.

I was too down in the dumps to stay for the second game, but if anything the draw plays into Starlights hands as it gives them at least an extra week to prepare. Fair play to them, they are worthy title contenders

beano (Wexford) - Posts: 1424 - 02/10/2017 10:10:54    2052298

Link

i was working yesterday but got some reaction from those leaving wexford,a replay is a disaster,because it means the county final will be put back further if st martins win next weekend.
surely,all these matches should be played to a conclusion?i.e. extra time?

perfect10 (Wexford) - Posts: 3929 - 02/10/2017 14:57:57    2052427

Link

It'll not matter if the Rapps win, no?

Pinkie (Wexford) - Posts: 4100 - 02/10/2017 17:04:36    2052486

Link

Likely to be 4 weeks until football final now. Semi replay is 2 weeks away and week after will be hurling final. Can't play both finals on same weekend as rapps / stars or st Martin's could be involved in both.
Extra time yesterday would have saved 2 weeks. Final played instead of semi replay.

freshoh (Wexford) - Posts: 131 - 02/10/2017 19:42:30    2052543

Link

Unfortunately thats the price of success in dual clubs. Crossabeg/Ballymurn out in leinster football this weekend so inter hurling semi is off im told.

hurler101 (Wexford) - Posts: 471 - 02/10/2017 20:53:15    2052562

Link

Replying To hurler101:  "Unfortunately thats the price of success in dual clubs. Crossabeg/Ballymurn out in leinster football this weekend so inter hurling semi is off im told."
In the Leinster Senior hurling club championship. The wexford champions got a bye in the 1st round scheduled for 5th November. And will play away to the winners of Dublin v Kilkenny champions on 19th November.

In the Leinster club senior football the Wexford champions are away to the Meath winners on the 12th November.

So surely then common sense would see
Martins v Shels football replay 15th October
County Senior Football Final 22nd October
County Senior Hurling Final 29th October

Giving both winners 3 weeks to celebrate and prepare for Leinster.

If they go with the hurling final on the 22nd and the football on the 29th it leaves the Starlights waiting 4 weeks between winning semi and the final which in my opinion is to long a gap.

And gives the hurling winners a 4 week gap til the game against winners of Dublin v Kilkenny champions which I think is to long and leave them undercooked.

And reduces the celebrations and preparation time to the wexford football winners to 2 weeks

But we will see what the powers to be will decide... And I agree and think from 1/4 finals on should be decided on the day via extra time

wexwanderer (Wexford) - Posts: 22 - 02/10/2017 23:26:08    2052584

Link

On the semi finals I only seen the first game and then the first half of the 2nd game due to work commitments.

Starlights have an abundance of speed in every line and will fancy their chances coupled with a decent bench and good management.

Surprised Castletown took of James Holmes so early in the 2nd half as he was playing well. Brosnan scored some excellent points in the second half put should of came out the field when starved of possession to get on more ball.

Nick Doyle and Liam Ryan lorded midfield as Castletown will regret over working the ball in promising positions straight in front of the posts and passing wide to worse positioned team mates who shot wide or lost possession in the first half. They also played into the Starlights hands by slowing the game down and focusing on keeping possession and lateral passing when 05-02 points up after 20 minutes and allowed starlights back into the game.

Instead of driving hard at the heart of their defence which was proving successful and yielded similar rewards late in 2nd half when Castletown through off the shackles and had to go for it.

Starlights switching of Jack Kelly and Kevin Foley out to the half back line from the full back line and the introduction of Arron Dobbs around the 20 minute mark both changed the momentum of the game.

They do look weaker defensively than the Shels or Martins but look to have more as a unit from midfield up without having the stand out marquee forward.

And in Ricky Fox Ryan Mahon and Kevin Foley in particular have some very intelligent playmakers.

Shels will regret not putting the Martins away but I think they just might get the job done the next day as their style of play troubles the Martins.

And in fairness I don't think overall their is much between the teams.

And contradictory enough I think if Shels win the replay the Starlights would take them in the final.

But if the Martins win i think the power and direct running of their forwards will be to much for the Starlights backline and their midfield pairing will stop the supply to the nippy starlights forwards by stopping the influence of Nick Doyle and Gypo.

The excellent kickouts by Pa Doyle are another big factor for the Starlights.

All in all the 4 best teams are in the county were on show and the games were a big step up from the fair the beaten 1/4 finalists showed bar Glynn who I would put in the same bracket as the semi finalists.

wexwanderer (Wexford) - Posts: 22 - 02/10/2017 23:55:08    2052592

Link

Replying To freshoh:  "Likely to be 4 weeks until football final now. Semi replay is 2 weeks away and week after will be hurling final. Can't play both finals on same weekend as rapps / stars or st Martin's could be involved in both.
Extra time yesterday would have saved 2 weeks. Final played instead of semi replay."
I'm happy to see another exciting game of football and hopefully we will have a new manager by that stage who can watch the final

hurlorhurley (Wexford) - Posts: 1660 - 03/10/2017 06:03:55    2052600

Link

Replying To hurler101:  "Unfortunately thats the price of success in dual clubs. Crossabeg/Ballymurn out in leinster football this weekend so inter hurling semi is off im told."
It's a great opportunity for a club who have worked really hard at football over the past ten years to show their talents on the provincial stage

hurlorhurley (Wexford) - Posts: 1660 - 03/10/2017 06:05:19    2052601

Link

I see the fixtures committee are pulling a fast one this weekend with the junior hurling semi final replay not on until next wend even though this is a hurling wend

mrfox (Wexford) - Posts: 338 - 03/10/2017 10:32:36    2052632

Link

I see the fixtures committee are pulling a fast one this weekend with the junior hurling semi final replay not on until next wend even though this is a hurling wend

mrfox (Wexford) - Posts: 338 - 03/10/2017 10:55:53    2052641

Link

Replying To hurlorhurley:  "I'm happy to see another exciting game of football and hopefully we will have a new manager by that stage who can watch the final"
Maybe he will be involved in the final

mrfox (Wexford) - Posts: 338 - 03/10/2017 10:57:43    2052642

Link

Replying To mrfox:  "I see the fixtures committee are pulling a fast one this weekend with the junior hurling semi final replay not on until next wend even though this is a hurling wend"
Yeah that ones surprises me. What's stopping that junior replay being played this weekend

890202 (Wexford) - Posts: 1278 - 03/10/2017 12:19:52    2052672

Link

Replying To mrfox:  "I see the fixtures committee are pulling a fast one this weekend with the junior hurling semi final replay not on until next wend even though this is a hurling wend"
Yeah I seen that with the junior semi final replay... What is the reason it is not on this weekend

Will the junior final be on a Saturday? Probably likely to be the 28th of October then

wexwanderer (Wexford) - Posts: 22 - 03/10/2017 12:29:05    2052677

Link

Replying To wexwanderer:  "Yeah I seen that with the junior semi final replay... What is the reason it is not on this weekend

Will the junior final be on a Saturday? Probably likely to be the 28th of October then"
Horswood have a wedding on. The seem to be the only club that can get a free weekend when they want

mrfox (Wexford) - Posts: 338 - 03/10/2017 13:38:24    2052700

Link

Replying To mrfox:  "Horswood have a wedding on. The seem to be the only club that can get a free weekend when they want"
Normally the best that most other clubs can do is to get one day of a weekend free for a wedding. The whole weekend is too generous but I suppose that's the advantage of having a club member in power

890202 (Wexford) - Posts: 1278 - 03/10/2017 14:30:56    2052718

Link

Predictions for the weekend -
Gorey v st Martins - ill go for a st martins win but i think they arent going that great. Gorey probably just not good enough
Rapps v Oulart - Oulart are a team that is fading and the Rapps have been very impressive. If they can keep Garret Sinnott quiet then ill go for them

St Annes v Bunclody - St Annes won this fixture when they played in the league stages but i think bunclody are going better now and i expect them to win

Duffry v Fethard - Both of these teams are better than 3/4 of the teams in the higher grade but i think the duffry will win this one. They have been going very well, i suppose fethard have aswell but ill just about give the duffry the nod.

Junior B semi-final - Adamstown v Oylegate - Adamstown seem to get this far every year but cant seem to progress any further, and i think the same will happen again. Oylegate for me.

890202 (Wexford) - Posts: 1278 - 06/10/2017 11:07:00    2053514

Link