PETER CANAVAN column

June 14, 2007
A crumbling empire? "The Roman Empire ruled the developed world for nearly a century and disappeared in about 20 years" - Peter Quinn (President of the GAA 1991-94) The most important aspect that came out of Congress in April this year was not any of the decisions taken by the policy makers of the GAA but the comments made by Peter Quinn prior to the gathering in Kilkenny. It was no co-incidence that Quinn's opinions were made known days before Congress. His forthright views I'm sure were discussed and debated more so than some of the motions raised on the clar. The "Quinn direct" approach centres on the lack of vision for the future of the GAA. He pulls no punches when claiming that our association has become dangerously complacent, is over staffed and is failing to plan properly for the many challenges it faces. Quinn goes as far to suggest that the GAA is under serious risk over the next 20 years unless there a radical change of attitude at all levels. For such startling statements to come from someone as distinguished as Quinn should serve as a wake up call to many in our association. Peter Quinn is not a man to make such comments lightly. His renowned business acumen makes him well versed to comment on the ever expanding commercial side of the GAA but he also has his finger on the pulse as to what is happening at grass roots level. One month into the 2007 championship are there signs that the GAA is still basking in the glory of the redeveloped Croke Park? Is there still a lap of honour taking place? I would like to be in a position where I could disagree with Quinn but I can't. Only weeks into the Championship and there is evidence that things are not going as well as they should be. Attendances appear to be well down on last year. The pricing structure and marketing strategy for Championship games leaves a lot to be desired. In Ulster after the first round clash between Tyrone and Fermanagh I lost count of the number of people complaining about the admission cost not only to the Gerry Arthurs stand but to the terraces as well. In terms of promoting the games there was only minimal evidence of it both in terms of print and TV. The net result was that less than 13,000 attended the game. This was a disappointing figure especially when you consider that there was more at the corresponding NFL fixture in Omagh back at the start of February! 25 euro for uncovered accommodation is simply too high (granted children under 16 were allowed in free). There are a number of reasons why the prices must come down. Firstly cheaper prices will naturally lead to a higher number of people attending games. A bigger crowd will lead to a better atmosphere. Players respond better in a setting whereby the stadium is full rather than half empty. For those watching on TV the game is enhanced right away by the noise, colour and excitement generated. As well as Tyrone and Fermanagh, the Cork ad Limerick game did not make for good viewing due to the empty seats and lack of atmosphere. For those viewing on TV not only does a full capacity make for a better spectacle but it will probably encourage them to actually attend more games as they feel they are missing out something. In an age when we are competing against other sports for the youth of our country why does the GAA insist in shooting ourselves in the foot? Remember we maybe competing against these sports but we don't need to be putting similar pricing structures in place. I fail to see the logic behind raising ticket prices this year. The GAA will take in millions of pounds this year through the hurling and football championships. With lower prices millions will still be generated and a much better image of our games will be portrayed. Quinn's concern that competition from other sports will present a massive threat to the GAA over the next 20 years is a valid one. Not only do other sports affect us but currently the format and structure of our County Championship appear to be having an adverse affect. More and more club players are becoming disgruntled and disillusioned by the lack of competitive fixtures during the summer months. With fixtures thrown into disarray, club players summer football depends solely on the progress of the county team. The lack of a club master plan not only leaves it difficult for planning holidays it also leaves it impossible for managers and coaches to plan their training schedule. I find it ironic that when the issue of county players welfare is debated so many administrators refer to the 'grass roots' and loyal club player, yet when it comes to the future of the club player the powers that be show scant regard and lack the visionary approach necessary to keep our games at a healthy level. Prior to the championship commencing I suggested that it would be very unlikely for another county to break the Tyrone/Kerry grip on the Sam Maguire. One month into the championship and already there are signs that this stranglehold could be broken. For starters it appears that Brain McGuigan's eye injury could well keep him out of the entire championship. If this is the case then it seriously diminishes Tyrone's chances of winning another All-Ireland. Donegal and Galway have both relieved Armagh and Mayo of their provincial crowns and in doing so have put themselves up there with the big boys. On their day Galway and Donegal are capable of beating anyone. Wicklow's extended run in the Leinster championship has been one of the highlights so far. Let's face it no-one gave them a chance of competing with Louth - a team that took Tyrone (then All-Ireland Champions) to a replay last year. Mick O'Dwyer take a bow.

Most Read Stories