National Forum

Galway Football thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To LetsPlayBall:  "Lets not forget Moycullen drew with Litir Mor and came close to being bet to a very poor Strokestown team.
The going has yet to get tough for them, Ulster champions will be a massive test for them and will really tell us where they are at."
Rather than forget it, I had literally made the point that they struggled in a few games against teams they were expected to beat more comfortably.
They rose to the occasion when the stakes were highest though. I'd also echo the comment above that Strokestown are far from a poor team.
Roscommon winners are always highly competitive and have a better recent record than the Mayo champions.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 2034 - 10/12/2022 09:15:30    2450008

Link

Replying To TheBishop:  "Owen Gallagher clearly better in possession, a better fielder and a lot more comfortable in front of the posts then O'Laoi. Must be something in the stats that isn't obvious to us as from the obvious attributes Gallagher is a better footballer. Paul Kelly another footballer who plays a similar role to O'Laoi who is a better footballer.

Interesting to see who'll take Molloys & Silke's position in the league. McGrath, Sweeney, Mannion & Foley are the obvious candidates. McGrath & Sweeney along with Jack Glynn were the standout defenders in the last 3 years in the u20's. Tony Gill another one but difficult for him given the strength of the Corofin half back line.

Nearly forgot about Cian Hernon, not sure where's upto after his cruciate injury, fairly sure he didn't play any football in 2022."
Of All the Players People Have Mentioned To Compete For a Place
Billy Mannion is the one Player I Want to See Given A Chance
He Has Been Very Good For Mountbellew The Last Few Years
He Is a Very Good Defender Good Man Marker
He is Also Very Good on The Ball Calm and Composed
It Was a Mystery to Me Why he Did Not Play in League or Championship
Until That is The All IRE Quarter final in Extra Time Crazy i Know
But In That Short time He Set up A Goal For Cillian Mc Daid and and also set up a Point
He Could if Hes Given A Run of Games Do a Job in the Full Back Line for Galway
Therefore Freeing up Sean Kelly To Be More Advanced and Show His Ability

rhudson (Galway) - Posts: 1478 - 10/12/2022 14:15:35    2450038

Link

I think Sean kelly best position is in full back line he rarely kicks the ball which in my opinion is vital if ur in halfback line in full back line u get away with it ,

Kickitout (Galway) - Posts: 832 - 10/12/2022 17:26:27    2450066

Link

Wouldn't be in the slightest bit impressed by the quality in that Ulster final yesterday. Can say Moycullen winning at their ease.

TanCanRan (Galway) - Posts: 179 - 12/12/2022 13:45:23    2450187

Link

Would love to see a Crokes Moycullen final just to see a battle between Shane and Sean Kelly. That would be worth the admission alone. Moycullen probably in a 50-50 game against Glen although Moycullen probably have a better balance to their 15.

galway19 (Galway) - Posts: 672 - 12/12/2022 15:25:22    2450208

Link

Replying To rhudson:  "Of All the Players People Have Mentioned To Compete For a Place
Billy Mannion is the one Player I Want to See Given A Chance
He Has Been Very Good For Mountbellew The Last Few Years
He Is a Very Good Defender Good Man Marker
He is Also Very Good on The Ball Calm and Composed
It Was a Mystery to Me Why he Did Not Play in League or Championship
Until That is The All IRE Quarter final in Extra Time Crazy i Know
But In That Short time He Set up A Goal For Cillian Mc Daid and and also set up a Point
He Could if Hes Given A Run of Games Do a Job in the Full Back Line for Galway
Therefore Freeing up Sean Kelly To Be More Advanced and Show His Ability"
The fact that on his debut in a QF he relaxed so much into the game is brilliant. Plenty of lads have the talent but not the head to match. Nerves can get the better of even the best of lads. That pass to Cillian was perfect. Definitely want to see more of him

galwayfball (Galway) - Posts: 1678 - 12/12/2022 15:47:30    2450213

Link

Replying To TanCanRan:  "Wouldn't be in the slightest bit impressed by the quality in that Ulster final yesterday. Can say Moycullen winning at their ease."
The intensity in the contest was impressive was as close to inter County game you would likely get this time of the year and Glen holding the defending All-Ireland champions to a mere 1-6 was impressive.

Cooke v Glass makes for intriguing match up.

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 3337 - 12/12/2022 16:42:55    2450226

Link

Glen will be warm favourites against Moycullen I feel. They have an awful lot of hype around them at the moment. And they are a good side in fairness. I think Moycullen have a right decent chance though and of course Derry teams have an absolutely woeful record against Galway sides in general.

Marooned (Galway) - Posts: 2208 - 12/12/2022 19:24:15    2450241

Link

NUIG with a very strong panel in this Sigerson. Could retain it with the strength they have.

galway19 (Galway) - Posts: 672 - 14/12/2022 16:26:48    2450421

Link

Replying To Gaa_lover:  "The intensity in the contest was impressive was as close to inter County game you would likely get this time of the year and Glen holding the defending All-Ireland champions to a mere 1-6 was impressive.

Cooke v Glass makes for intriguing match up."
All perspiration with very little inspiration was the Ulster final. Quality was lower than a snakes belly. It was exciting don't get me wrong but hard to be blown away by any class.

TanCanRan (Galway) - Posts: 179 - 14/12/2022 16:56:52    2450427

Link

Just wondering about people's opinions on the top Gaa clubs in Galway. Separate top 10 for football .
Basing results on getting the best out of the numbers they have at underage and adult level
Football.
1 Moycullen
2 Corofin
3 Dunmore
4 Claregalway
5 Salthill Knocknacarra
6 Mountbellew
7 killanin
8 Annaghdown
9 St Michael's
10 Milltown.

Belclare (Galway) - Posts: 904 - 14/12/2022 18:49:27    2450438

Link

how far off a return is james mcloughlin. it is a long time since his operation. didnt realise it was that serious at the time.

Mayonman (Galway) - Posts: 1826 - 15/12/2022 08:47:30    2450450

Link

Replying To Belclare:  "Just wondering about people's opinions on the top Gaa clubs in Galway. Separate top 10 for football .
Basing results on getting the best out of the numbers they have at underage and adult level
Football.
1 Moycullen
2 Corofin
3 Dunmore
4 Claregalway
5 Salthill Knocknacarra
6 Mountbellew
7 killanin
8 Annaghdown
9 St Michael's
10 Milltown."
Very hard to rank these.

For Corofin, you could argue they are top because of their high retention rate of players. Keeping their players playing adult football, which is definitely helped by the many options of adult teams they have, for lads of all standards and interest levels.

Dunmore deserve serious credit for the work they have put in recently. I think any rural club should look at Dunmore as a great example of what can be done with small numbers and a club wanting to improve and work together for the betterment of the club.

Claregalway have improved at holding onto young talents and I think they will continue to improve as there seems to be an increased community feel to the club in recent years. However, their drop off rate for various reasons has been noticeably poor. They would have multiple Frank Foxs if they held on to all of their underage talent in recent years. S/K the same, but you will always have a higher drop out rate in the city. And to be fair to S/K they have brought through a young team full of new leaders, so they can be saved some criticism here.

M/M similar to Corofin, need to be applauded for their retention rate of players. Always in the business end of championship and wouldnt have huge numbers.

Killanin doing well based on numbers.

Annaghdown are a club with a big playing base who havent done much in underage in recent years. From speaking to an Annaghdown man, it is an issue they need to address soon. In saying that, they have been introducing one or two to the senior panel every year recently and that is key for any club.

St Michaels are doing well based on what they have. I'm sure they would love to retain more players but again this is an obvious issue in city clubs.

Milltown need to be credited for punching above their weight in recent years. Their underage is struggling and I would assume they have the oldest panel in senior football, and only for luck and the way the fixtures fell, they would have been in the last 8 again. That's an achievement in itself.

Impossible to rank these clubs as there are a lot of different factors to consider. Do you rank Claregalway higher than Milltown? A club with multiple underage teams per age group, or a team struggling desperately for numbers who are consistent at senior level? Unless there is a clear weighting system, it is very hard to put one 'over' the other.

All clubs are trying their best and have different issues that effect them.

GalwaysFinest (Galway) - Posts: 190 - 15/12/2022 11:35:47    2450469

Link

Replying To galway19:  "NUIG with a very strong panel in this Sigerson. Could retain it with the strength they have."
Do you Know Whos in The Panel
Is There Many From Galway

rhudson (Galway) - Posts: 1478 - 15/12/2022 12:09:29    2450473

Link

Replying To rhudson:  "Do you Know Whos in The Panel
Is There Many From Galway"
1 Colin Murray Mountbellew Galway
2 Conor Carroll Oranmore Roscommon
3 Rory Egan Edenderry Offaly
4 Cathal Donoghue Kilcormac Offaly
5 Cian Monaghan Oughterard Galway
6 Ryan Monaghan Oughterard Galway
7 Donal Hunt Salthill Galway
8 Mark McInerney Eire Og Clare
9 Gavin Burke Corofin Galway
10 Patrick O Donnell Aran Galway
11 Darragh Heneghan Michael Glaveys Roscommon
12 Liam Brady Ramor United Cavan
13 Evan Lyons Shamrock Gaels Sligo
14 Cathal Sweeney Salthill Galway
15 Eoghan Kelly Moycullen Galway
16 Paul McGrath St.Brigid's Roscommon
17 Sean Kelly Moycullen Galway
18 Tomo Culhane Salthill Galway
19 Sean O Flynn Courtwood Laois
20 Paul Kelly Moycullen Galway
21 Diarmuid Kilcommins Annaghdown Galway
22 Tommy Conroy The Neale Mayo
23 Matthew Tierney Oughterard Galway
24 Nathan Mullen Mullinabreena Sligo
25 Shane McGrath Dunmore Galway
26 Conor Dunleavy Balla Mayo
27 Conor Corcoran Moycullen Galway
28 Cillian Golding Balla Mayo
29 Cillian O Curraoin Micheal Breathnach
30 Conal Gallagher St Michaels Galway
31 Rob Walzer Salthill Galway
32 James McLoughlin Moycullen Galway
33 Mark Moran Westport Mayo
34 Dan Cox Moycullen Galway
35 Daniel Flaherty Salthill Galway

GalwaysFinest (Galway) - Posts: 190 - 15/12/2022 12:42:43    2450479

Link

Replying To rhudson:  "Do you Know Whos in The Panel
Is There Many From Galway"
Matthew Tierney, Culhane and Cathal Sweeney are still there along with Donal Hunt (Salthill), Gavin Burke, Colin Murray, Diarmuid Kilcommins so a lot of last year's winning side. Add in Tommy Conroy and Mark Moran from Mayo as well. They also have six Moycullen lads who will play some part in the competition with Sean Kelly, Paul Kelly, Eoghan Kelly, James McLoughlin, Conor Corcoran and Daniel Cox. 20 of the 35 are from Galway.

galway19 (Galway) - Posts: 672 - 15/12/2022 12:44:03    2450480

Link

Replying To GalwaysFinest:  "Very hard to rank these.

For Corofin, you could argue they are top because of their high retention rate of players. Keeping their players playing adult football, which is definitely helped by the many options of adult teams they have, for lads of all standards and interest levels.

Dunmore deserve serious credit for the work they have put in recently. I think any rural club should look at Dunmore as a great example of what can be done with small numbers and a club wanting to improve and work together for the betterment of the club.

Claregalway have improved at holding onto young talents and I think they will continue to improve as there seems to be an increased community feel to the club in recent years. However, their drop off rate for various reasons has been noticeably poor. They would have multiple Frank Foxs if they held on to all of their underage talent in recent years. S/K the same, but you will always have a higher drop out rate in the city. And to be fair to S/K they have brought through a young team full of new leaders, so they can be saved some criticism here.

M/M similar to Corofin, need to be applauded for their retention rate of players. Always in the business end of championship and wouldnt have huge numbers.

Killanin doing well based on numbers.

Annaghdown are a club with a big playing base who havent done much in underage in recent years. From speaking to an Annaghdown man, it is an issue they need to address soon. In saying that, they have been introducing one or two to the senior panel every year recently and that is key for any club.

St Michaels are doing well based on what they have. I'm sure they would love to retain more players but again this is an obvious issue in city clubs.

Milltown need to be credited for punching above their weight in recent years. Their underage is struggling and I would assume they have the oldest panel in senior football, and only for luck and the way the fixtures fell, they would have been in the last 8 again. That's an achievement in itself.

Impossible to rank these clubs as there are a lot of different factors to consider. Do you rank Claregalway higher than Milltown? A club with multiple underage teams per age group, or a team struggling desperately for numbers who are consistent at senior level? Unless there is a clear weighting system, it is very hard to put one 'over' the other.

All clubs are trying their best and have different issues that effect them."
The top 10 doesn't need to be in any order in reality..
It's a numbers game .. Claregalway have large numbers of coaches and players compared to Milltown Kilconly etc . Milltown had a great win in Minor this year, and indeed are punchng above their weight at senior. There's a great community spirit in all these clubs, they are all working hard with what they have.

Belclare (Galway) - Posts: 904 - 15/12/2022 14:01:35    2450492

Link

Replying To Mayonman:  "how far off a return is james mcloughlin. it is a long time since his operation. didnt realise it was that serious at the time."
Was wondering that myself. He's been out for a good while now. Played a small bit in the FBD last January but has barely been since since. I know he had surgery at some stage but thought he would be back by now.

Marooned (Galway) - Posts: 2208 - 15/12/2022 15:25:13    2450499

Link

Replying To galway19:  "NUIG with a very strong panel in this Sigerson. Could retain it with the strength they have."
Round 1 and 2 of the Sigerson cup on 10th and 17th of January if Moycullen reach the All-Ireland final it will be played on the 21st so can imagine those lads will have little or no involvement?

Yondu (UK) - Posts: 845 - 15/12/2022 16:09:46    2450505

Link

Replying To TanCanRan:  "All perspiration with very little inspiration was the Ulster final. Quality was lower than a snakes belly. It was exciting don't get me wrong but hard to be blown away by any class."
Not sure what game you watched. Was plenty of inspiration in the term of team defending and midfield play and the winners Glenn was clinical when when they needed to be.

It will be interesting to see how Glen and Moycullens style of play transfers into Croke Park its could well be two well matched teams cancelling each other out.

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 3337 - 15/12/2022 16:15:34    2450507

Link