|
Replying To SouthGalway: "Does anyone know if Michael Cusacks (Kilbeacanty and Beagh) will ever have a Senior Hurling team? They do fairly well at Underage but have no Senior Team. Just wondering." Not for now. They're both able to field at adult level. Underage was obviously different, when you need bigger numbers at each age group. They have a very good crop of lads either side of U15. I understand it's mainly Beagh in that group, but I'm open to correction.
WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3047 - 07/09/2026 16:50:35
2693076
Link
0
|
|
Replying To WanPintWin: "We've been over this before. The clubs voted quite strongly in favour of the new format. We had a ridiculous situation under the old format of senior players from big clubs playing the first few rounds of the Junior championship. It was very unfair to whoever met them in the first few games.
We'll see how it goes over the next few years. I wouldn't be so sure it will pan out as you say, based on your other predictions." It's the Junior Clubs who are crying about trying to promote hurling, it's their choice to enter the hurling Championship. Therefore if you enter the lions den you better be prepared to fight the Lion! In others words get their own house in order and stop ridiculing hurling Clubs who have strong 2nd teams.
Annaghdown got their house in order 25yrs ago and won Junior C,B and A alll the way upto the old Intermediate Championship.
There is poor aul Tuam playing Junior F trying to promote hurling, yet if they became successful they can't get promoted to Premier Junior became the highest level they can go is Reeves Cup!
katser (Galway) - Posts: 2943 - 07/09/2026 18:22:46
2693080
Link
0
|
|
Replying To WanPintWin: "Not for now. They're both able to field at adult level. Underage was obviously different, when you need bigger numbers at each age group. They have a very good crop of lads either side of U15. I understand it's mainly Beagh in that group, but I'm open to correction." They got to the Feile division 1 final this year.
Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 20652 - 07/09/2026 18:32:30
2693082
Link
0
|
|
Replying To galway19: "It could be a tight enough game alright but I'd be very surprised if Craughwell don't go through in the end. Tom Monaghan and Tiarnan Leen in midfield have come to form in last two games and they are as good in that area of the field as any team in the competition. Josh Ryan took Monaghan completely out of the game against Clarinbridge but not many teams have that sort of man marking option to nullify him, especially with his pace and shooting. Ciaran Leen and Jamie Ryan starting to hit form as well and they have a few new options up front with Zimmerer and McCartin. Ardrahan very solid at the back but I don't think they have the scoring power to win games at knockout stage.
One way or another it is going to set up four belters of quarter finals no matter what way the draw goes. You could have Clarinbridge v St Thomas' or a repeat of the Bridge Loughrea game last year. Sarsfields v Turloughmore would be a mighty game as well. Larkins I believe picked up some injuries at the weekend so they need those to clear for a months time. Athenry building nicely after topping their group." If ardrahan have Brian callanan fully fit they will win in my opinion. I believe Cianan fahy and Tom Monaghan will fairly even each other out and I think the likes of Michael Walsh and Conor cosgrove are better answers to leen and Pendergast then what Craughwell have for the likes of Callanan (if fit) as well as the gardiners who got 3 each against turlough
Loughrea22 (Galway) - Posts: 4 - 07/09/2026 22:41:02
2693100
Link
0
|
|
Replying To katser: "It's the Junior Clubs who are crying about trying to promote hurling, it's their choice to enter the hurling Championship. Therefore if you enter the lions den you better be prepared to fight the Lion! In others words get their own house in order and stop ridiculing hurling Clubs who have strong 2nd teams.
Annaghdown got their house in order 25yrs ago and won Junior C,B and A alll the way upto the old Intermediate Championship.
There is poor aul Tuam playing Junior F trying to promote hurling, yet if they became successful they can't get promoted to Premier Junior became the highest level they can go is Reeves Cup!" Why can't Tuam be promoted to Premier Junior in time ?
John Doe (Galway) - Posts: 259 - 08/09/2026 07:51:47
2693106
Link
0
|
|
Replying To katser: "It's the Junior Clubs who are crying about trying to promote hurling, it's their choice to enter the hurling Championship. Therefore if you enter the lions den you better be prepared to fight the Lion! In others words get their own house in order and stop ridiculing hurling Clubs who have strong 2nd teams.
Annaghdown got their house in order 25yrs ago and won Junior C,B and A alll the way upto the old Intermediate Championship.
There is poor aul Tuam playing Junior F trying to promote hurling, yet if they became successful they can't get promoted to Premier Junior became the highest level they can go is Reeves Cup!" An Spidéal also went from Junior C to old intermediate. They won Junior A which included the second teams of larger clubs. The hurlball clubs as you call them were able to compete. The issue was they were often facing teams with senior players early in the championship. It made a mockery of it.
A couple of things:
All hurling clubs got to vote on the new structure and it passed with almost 70%. There are far more hurling only clubs than dual clubs, so plenty hurling only clubs voted for it too. You can keep giving out about it, but it's what the clubs wanted.
You're also wrong about Tuam. If they do manage to get up to Junior A and win it, then they would be in Premier Junior, as they're a first team. They have a long way to go to get to the level, but would be great to see it.
WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3047 - 08/09/2026 08:13:36
2693107
Link
0
|
|
Replying To WanPintWin: "An Spidéal also went from Junior C to old intermediate. They won Junior A which included the second teams of larger clubs. The hurlball clubs as you call them were able to compete. The issue was they were often facing teams with senior players early in the championship. It made a mockery of it.
A couple of things:
All hurling clubs got to vote on the new structure and it passed with almost 70%. There are far more hurling only clubs than dual clubs, so plenty hurling only clubs voted for it too. You can keep giving out about it, but it's what the clubs wanted.
You're also wrong about Tuam. If they do manage to get up to Junior A and win it, then they would be in Premier Junior, as they're a first team. They have a long way to go to get to the level, but would be great to see it." Your spot on over the last few years the second teams ran up big scores in the earlier rounds but as the competition progressed they lost players to their senior team resulting in getting hammered when the knockout started often to cost of teams that they played earlier
minor77 (Galway) - Posts: 319 - 08/09/2026 10:14:46
2693120
Link
0
|
|
Replying To John Doe: "Why can't Tuam be promoted to Premier Junior in time ?" Under the current rules there is no promotion to Premier Junior, so the highest grade a Club can go is Reeves Cup.
From Junior F,E,D,C,B,A and then Reeves Cup. Madness!!
katser (Galway) - Posts: 2943 - 08/09/2026 10:29:16
2693121
Link
0
|
|
Replying To WanPintWin: "An Spidéal also went from Junior C to old intermediate. They won Junior A which included the second teams of larger clubs. The hurlball clubs as you call them were able to compete. The issue was they were often facing teams with senior players early in the championship. It made a mockery of it.
A couple of things:
All hurling clubs got to vote on the new structure and it passed with almost 70%. There are far more hurling only clubs than dual clubs, so plenty hurling only clubs voted for it too. You can keep giving out about it, but it's what the clubs wanted.
You're also wrong about Tuam. If they do manage to get up to Junior A and win it, then they would be in Premier Junior, as they're a first team. They have a long way to go to get to the level, but would be great to see it." The whole idea of sport is to be competitive against the best and if a hurling Clubs 2nd team is strong....so what try harder to beat them!
That Premier Junior is not competitive, 2 groups of 5 with the top 4 from each group into QF, so basically lose 3 of the 4 group games and your in QF!
What have poor Barna/Furbo got from it....3 losses 1 draw sitting bottom of the barrel season over!
Forgot about An Spidéal great achievement, so there you go it can be done winning and competing against hurling Clubs strong 2nd or 3rd teams.
There is Barna Furbo getting a free ride in Premier Junior when you should earn your status to stay in the 3rd tier!
That rule about Clubs Senior players you could always regrade 6 Senior players to Junior but now a Clubs Senior team have to play first before their Junior team plays so normally the regraded players end up playing Senior again.
katser (Galway) - Posts: 2943 - 08/09/2026 10:54:54
2693127
Link
0
|
|
Replying To katser: "Under the current rules there is no promotion to Premier Junior, so the highest grade a Club can go is Reeves Cup.
From Junior F,E,D,C,B,A and then Reeves Cup. Madness!!" No promotion for second teams. Tuam would be promoted to premier junior if they won Junior A.
WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3047 - 08/09/2026 11:01:08
2693129
Link
1
|
|
I met up with some friends after racing last evening and one of the group commented the comment that the lady involved in hurling draws on GBfm made about Moycullen being the unluckiest team in the competition was surprisingly agreed by 5 of 6 present, it must be said that only 2 two saw the game.It was said that if the controversial goal had stood that Loughrea would have being depending on Tommy L to keep them in the championship.I wonder is that lady's view held by more?
backtooldwall (Galway) - Posts: 254 - 08/09/2026 11:08:12
2693130
Link
0
|
|
Reeves cup is a waste of time for certain teams in it, mostly a waste of time for the junior a clubs that are now having to compete with intermediate teams.
If ya look at the reeves cup group 1. You have turlough, craughwell (Both were intermediate) in a group with Sarsfeilds and Thomas's both top junior A teams last year in the group with Ardrahan who only ever get out the group of junior A because the first few games they have senior players in with them and cappytaggle who are the same boat as ardrahan. That group finnished exactly how it would be predicted too. Turlough, Craughwell, Sarsfeilds , Thomas's , Ardrahan then cappy. Some of the scorelines too were ridiculous. Going through one game Ardrahan 1-6 , Sarsfeilds 2-22. Ardrahan losing to turlough 15 points. Cappy not even playing there two games to Turlough and Craughwell. Where is the benefit to these lower end junior A second teams in going out and getting hurled around the field. Now group 2 was more competitive but you still some ridiculously one sided games like mellows losing 0-06 to 1-21.
Realistically your going to have the same 4 teams reaching a semi final for the foreseeable.
I dont know how the vote went but i seen here 70 percent voted in favour. Id like to know of the 30 percent who didnt vote yes, how many of them clubs are currently in the reeves cup unwillingly. How many Premier junior clubs voted yes to it to have an easier chance at finally winning some silver wear? If you cant beat a clubs second team in junior as a first team you just simply are not good enough to win junior then.
Hurlingmind35 (Galway) - Posts: 3 - 08/09/2026 13:24:52
2693149
Link
0
|
|
Replying To katser: "The whole idea of sport is to be competitive against the best and if a hurling Clubs 2nd team is strong....so what try harder to beat them!
That Premier Junior is not competitive, 2 groups of 5 with the top 4 from each group into QF, so basically lose 3 of the 4 group games and your in QF!
What have poor Barna/Furbo got from it....3 losses 1 draw sitting bottom of the barrel season over!
Forgot about An Spidéal great achievement, so there you go it can be done winning and competing against hurling Clubs strong 2nd or 3rd teams.
There is Barna Furbo getting a free ride in Premier Junior when you should earn your status to stay in the 3rd tier!
That rule about Clubs Senior players you could always regrade 6 Senior players to Junior but now a Clubs Senior team have to play first before their Junior team plays so normally the regraded players end up playing Senior again." I'm sure all clubs and individuals will have their own ideas about 'the whole idea of sport'. Contrast Meelick and Carnmore 2026, for example. One has all wins in intermediate, and all losses in Junior A. The other has all losses in Intermediate, with a B team topping a Junior A table. Perhaps Carnmore aren't as good as Meelick at sorting the probables from the possibles.
Pope_Benedict (Galway) - Posts: 4908 - 08/09/2026 14:17:22
2693158
Link
1
|
|
Replying To Pope_Benedict: "I'm sure all clubs and individuals will have their own ideas about 'the whole idea of sport'. Contrast Meelick and Carnmore 2026, for example. One has all wins in intermediate, and all losses in Junior A. The other has all losses in Intermediate, with a B team topping a Junior A table. Perhaps Carnmore aren't as good as Meelick at sorting the probables from the possibles." I'm extremely surprised at how poor Carnmore are this year.....i would have them as a coming team for the future, bit like Ballindeeren lots of good young hurlers and very successful at underage.
Meelick-Eyrecourt are like Tynagh Abbey-Duniry no fear whatsoever and belive they are good enough to win Intermediate and compeat against below average Senior teams like Cappataggle, Killimordaly, Moycullen, Liam Mellows, Gort, Ardrahan.
I remember in 1998 Kiltormer won JHC A and JHC C but got nowhere in Intermediate when the Club was desperately trying to get back upto Senior.
katser (Galway) - Posts: 2943 - 08/09/2026 16:37:35
2693178
Link
1
|