HoganStand GAA Football and Hurling

National Forum

Who Makes These Decisions

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

You need to Login to Post

Why Why Why, Derry seniors play in Croke Park Saturday 25th the same day as their Minors play Galway in ?????????, Derry supporters/parents of minors now cannot go to see seniors play !!!!!!!!!! why not play a treble header in Croke Park, minor Derry v Gal at 12.30, followed by Derry v Clare in senior followed by Galway v Armagh. This logic would allow Derry & Galway fans to support BOTH their teams Following day Sunday 26th another treble header, Minor Mayo v Kerry at 12.30, followed by Mayo v Kerry in senior followed by Dublin v Cork This logic would allow Mayo & Kerry supporters to support both their Minor and Senior teams on the one day in the one venue, instead of traveling to see their minors on Saturday and then off again to Croke Park to support their seniors on Sunday Who makes these decisions !!!!!!!!! Minors deserve to play semi-finals in Croke Park, great preparation for the 2 finalists and a great experience for the beaten semi-finalists 1951andwaiting (Galway) - Posts: 84 - 13/06/2022 18:20:35 2424785 Link
The GAA don't care about the fans. They have basically downgraded the minor championships. They ruined the u21 grade too. yew_tree (Mayo) - Posts: 11237 - 13/06/2022 21:41:16 2424834 Link
Unfortunately, the GAA over the past several years has transitioned from a "patron" or "member" based model to that of a customer based model. Fans are commodities to be milked, and little more. He who pays the piper calls the tune. It is obvious that media corporations, private sponsors and corporate attendees (those paying for the expensive seats and boxes) have a lot more sway with the powers that be than ordinary members. The GAA should really drop the communitarian messaging in their marketing, because there are several recent incidences of them shelving home advantage/lower cost alternatives on the basis of "loadsamoney!" It's coming back to bite them now as people have obviously realised what's going on, as evidenced by recent low attendances at the Leinster SHC final and the football qualifier weekend. Gleebo (Mayo) - Posts: 2208 - 14/06/2022 08:12:13 2424844 Link
Replying To yew_tree: "The GAA don't care about the fans. They have basically downgraded the minor championships. They ruined the u21 grade too." They want to change it to U19 now. The U17 grade is more appropiate for development competitions like the Celtic Challange in hurling. The counties told them this when they went from U18 to U17. So now the plan is to merge the U20 and U17 into a single U19 grade. Just bring back the U21 as well. Rolo2010 (Donegal) - Posts: 739 - 14/06/2022 08:16:33 2424845 Link
Because you use you're brain ... unfortunately GAA hierarchy do not! Would have added so much more to the occasion for the minor players. hopballref (Galway) - Posts: 378 - 14/06/2022 08:55:45 2424853 Link
Replying To Rolo2010: "They want to change it to U19 now. The U17 grade is more appropiate for development competitions like the Celtic Challange in hurling. The counties told them this when they went from U18 to U17. So now the plan is to merge the U20 and U17 into a single U19 grade. Just bring back the U21 as well." The Gaa making it up as the go along The u21 grade was the right age for so many reasons I have heard people like peter Canavan and many involved in management of under age teams They have all questioned the change of grades they dont agree with it at all But its clear the gaa didnt consult with the people who really matter rhudson (Galway) - Posts: 1478 - 14/06/2022 09:55:42 2424877 Link
Replying To Rolo2010: "They want to change it to U19 now. The U17 grade is more appropiate for development competitions like the Celtic Challange in hurling. The counties told them this when they went from U18 to U17. So now the plan is to merge the U20 and U17 into a single U19 grade. Just bring back the U21 as well." Yeah it's a joke what they're doing. There clearly were issues to get around with U18 and U21 when doing leaving cert, in college and so on. But it worked, and was the base of underage for years and a route for young players to build through the grades and be fit to move towards senior. The current system shows it is hard for a 17yo to make it up to the U20 grade, and some are losing out on a year of playing. It was easier for an 18yo to do it in U21 level as they're a year stronger then. The move to U19 is just laughable for me. We need 2 grades (if not more actually, soccer has year grades for example) as how can any kid who turns 19 by the cut off at the start of the year be ready for senior football. What do they do for a few years until they can be ready? Some exceptional examples will always step up, but vast bulk of kids will fall behind here. They seem to be pushing for more Sigerson for some reason. It used to be a long weekend years ago, now they keep giving it more time. Colleges for me are not as important as the counties Loughduff Lad (Cavan) - Posts: 2407 - 14/06/2022 11:27:48 2424907 Link
Replying To Gleebo: "Unfortunately, the GAA over the past several years has transitioned from a "patron" or "member" based model to that of a customer based model. Fans are commodities to be milked, and little more. He who pays the piper calls the tune. It is obvious that media corporations, private sponsors and corporate attendees (those paying for the expensive seats and boxes) have a lot more sway with the powers that be than ordinary members. The GAA should really drop the communitarian messaging in their marketing, because there are several recent incidences of them shelving home advantage/lower cost alternatives on the basis of "loadsamoney!" It's coming back to bite them now as people have obviously realised what's going on, as evidenced by recent low attendances at the Leinster SHC final and the football qualifier weekend." 100% agree and its the wrong way to go. I think the pandemic got a lot of folks out of the habit of attending matches. The GAA should have been doing everything to get people back through the gates again. Its like watching the games die a slow death by 1,000 cuts at the moment. brianb (Kildare) - Posts: 292 - 14/06/2022 11:42:03 2424916 Link
Replying To Loughduff Lad: "Yeah it's a joke what they're doing. There clearly were issues to get around with U18 and U21 when doing leaving cert, in college and so on. But it worked, and was the base of underage for years and a route for young players to build through the grades and be fit to move towards senior. The current system shows it is hard for a 17yo to make it up to the U20 grade, and some are losing out on a year of playing. It was easier for an 18yo to do it in U21 level as they're a year stronger then. The move to U19 is just laughable for me. We need 2 grades (if not more actually, soccer has year grades for example) as how can any kid who turns 19 by the cut off at the start of the year be ready for senior football. What do they do for a few years until they can be ready? Some exceptional examples will always step up, but vast bulk of kids will fall behind here. They seem to be pushing for more Sigerson for some reason. It used to be a long weekend years ago, now they keep giving it more time. Colleges for me are not as important as the counties" U19 only works if you have U21 as well. U17 should be a development comp. I think we need a football version of the Tain Og to raise standards in weaker counties like Waterford. Rolo2010 (Donegal) - Posts: 739 - 14/06/2022 17:05:48 2425006 Link
60,000 tickets sold today for both sets of quarter finals. Not including season ticket holders which means Sunday week's matches already have 45,000 tickets sold. Pretty much debunks some nonsensical arguments earlier here re venues and spectators. Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 1505 - 14/06/2022 21:09:28 2425051 Link
Replying To Claretandblue: "60,000 tickets sold today for both sets of quarter finals. Not including season ticket holders which means Sunday week's matches already have 45,000 tickets sold. Pretty much debunks some nonsensical arguments earlier here re venues and spectators." It more backs them up to be honest. Look outside - it's summer now! Dublin are more than happy to play Saturday evening in Croke Park but I'll bet there won't be a lot of red in the crowd for that game. Sunday games are generally better attended and Kerry V Mayo is a genuine big game - Croke Park is the right place for the big games. But lets not gloss over some of the crazier decisions made about venues this year. A continuation of this were the points made here about minor fixtures not being considered at all as curtain raisers. Just because the top tier happily needs to be opened doesn't mean the fixtures committee have learned or that all is rosy in the garden. brianb (Kildare) - Posts: 292 - 15/06/2022 14:39:48 2425172 Link
Replying To 1951andwaiting: "Why Why Why, Derry seniors play in Croke Park Saturday 25th the same day as their Minors play Galway in ?????????, Derry supporters/parents of minors now cannot go to see seniors play !!!!!!!!!! why not play a treble header in Croke Park, minor Derry v Gal at 12.30, followed by Derry v Clare in senior followed by Galway v Armagh. This logic would allow Derry & Galway fans to support BOTH their teams Following day Sunday 26th another treble header, Minor Mayo v Kerry at 12.30, followed by Mayo v Kerry in senior followed by Dublin v Cork This logic would allow Mayo & Kerry supporters to support both their Minor and Senior teams on the one day in the one venue, instead of traveling to see their minors on Saturday and then off again to Croke Park to support their seniors on Sunday Who makes these decisions !!!!!!!!! Minors deserve to play semi-finals in Croke Park, great preparation for the 2 finalists and a great experience for the beaten semi-finalists" I heard that Galway objected to Croke Park as Derry would have more fans there that day and it would be unfair!! Not sure how true that is!! Tom1916 (Armagh) - Posts: 2001 - 15/06/2022 15:17:35 2425178 Link
Replying To Claretandblue: "60,000 tickets sold today for both sets of quarter finals. Not including season ticket holders which means Sunday week's matches already have 45,000 tickets sold. Pretty much debunks some nonsensical arguments earlier here re venues and spectators." Not necessarily, fixing a double header involving Sunday weeks football teams for Croker, taking into account geography and estimated attendances,, is a totally different kettle of fish to sending last Saturdays counties to Croker. Galway9801 (Galway) - Posts: 1726 - 15/06/2022 18:19:15 2425233 Link
Not a lot of red in Pairc Ui ring or Chaoimh so hardly fair to blame Croke Park for the lack of Cork supporters. Football fans in Cork are few and far between especially with hurlers still in championship. Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 1505 - 15/06/2022 21:10:29 2425254 Link
Too much being made of Croke Park for the 1-4 final games. Going to be great crowds in and atmosphere and players love Croker. AntrimJim (Antrim) - Posts: 39 - 16/06/2022 13:01:22 2425369 Link
Replying To Tom1916: "I heard that Galway objected to Croke Park as Derry would have more fans there that day and it would be unfair!! Not sure how true that is!!" Honestly don't know about an objection and I agree not ideal for Derry fans. Has not being in the nature of our board from previous but then again only speculating. However technically speaking fans if they wish and their travel arrangements allow one could get to the Derry minor game @1pm in PP and then their senior game @3.45pm in CP. Unsure why they could not have put the minor match on @2pm on the Sat in CP or indeed @12pm on the Sunday to facilitate Galway fans who would like to see their minors and seniors on the one programme. Kerry and Mayo could alternatively be on @ 12pm on the Sunday with their seniors playing later that day. kiloughter (Galway) - Posts: 1947 - 16/06/2022 14:00:40 2425395 Link
Nothing seems ideal for a lot of people. If your county get to Croke Park - embrace it AntrimJim (Antrim) - Posts: 39 - 16/06/2022 17:01:01 2425477 Link
Replying To AntrimJim: "Nothing seems ideal for a lot of people. If your county get to Croke Park - embrace it" The atmosphere is v poor tho unless you get a good crowd. Here in Galway, Kenny Park is in my opinion a far more enjoyable place to attend a game than its bigger more illustrious cousin in salthill. Galway9801 (Galway) - Posts: 1726 - 16/06/2022 17:44:47 2425490 Link
As the former great Wexford hurling manager Liam Griffin once said… "The GAA is the worst organised sport in the world":… and before anybody says that's rubbish… I heard him saying it…. and it's very hard to disagree with him….!!!! ForeverBlue2 (Cavan) - Posts: 1953 - 16/06/2022 18:41:37 2425502 Link
Replying To kiloughter: "Honestly don't know about an objection and I agree not ideal for Derry fans. Has not being in the nature of our board from previous but then again only speculating. However technically speaking fans if they wish and their travel arrangements allow one could get to the Derry minor game @1pm in PP and then their senior game @3.45pm in CP. Unsure why they could not have put the minor match on @2pm on the Sat in CP or indeed @12pm on the Sunday to facilitate Galway fans who would like to see their minors and seniors on the one programme. Kerry and Mayo could alternatively be on @ 12pm on the Sunday with their seniors playing later that day." Have Clare conceded? Seanfanbocht (Roscommon) - Posts: 1443 - 16/06/2022 19:06:33 2425507 Link