National Forum

Carlow GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


U-16 Regional final yesterday was a cracking game in awful conditions. Two late goals won it for the YIs but there's lots of talent coming through from that south west side. Nearly all dual players too.

Onion Breath (Carlow) - Posts: 1710 - 08/12/2025 13:46:45    2647481

Link

Replying To CARPS:  "And why are MLR thriving? Because they are a proper GAA club. Full service.

Old Leighlin, Ballinabranna and Leighlinbridge should copy them and form a dual club.

You'd be competing to win senior football and senior hurling every year. Could perhaps even win a Leinster."
Can't take underage success at anything more than face value. MLR continually produce great underage football teams the last while and some great players but hasn't amounted to anything really unfortunately.

Adult level their senior team could challenge but they don't pick up a football really until the hurling is done. The junior c side just exist for lads to kick ball, for a club that's "thriving underage" that should have bleed into the seniors challenging at the top of even pushing for upper end of junior B and lower end of Junior A. But sure look.

CarlowJuniorB (Clare) - Posts: 56 - 08/12/2025 13:48:26    2647482

Link

Replying To DolmenDave:  "Impressive win for MLR over Davitts today at 20s. I have to say, we were on high after beating Eire Og last week so a bit shell shocked. Granted Eire Og were definitely missing players but I thought we deserved the draw,if not the win. Eire Og had a young minor 16 year old at corner back who was excellent, a definite stand out on their first 15, and another young minor forward who came on as sub, who along with the normal Quinlan genius were the ones that MLR will need to look out for. Eire Og backs are much better than their forwards on last week's display but they will need to be because I have to say MLR, yet again at U20s football look outstanding. We were out battled on all levels today. What a job they have done with that club with both codes at all ages. Eire Og are supposedly the marque carlow club. But are they ? It's a friend's club in there. It's a whos who. Who you know. The rest of us are just trying to survive but MLR is proper community club at both codes. And it shows. And as a non MLR person I congratulate them for their hard work and as it showed today, the results they keep getting at all age levels and codes. It's a great gaa story in our small county and they deserve all the credit they get. A ray of hope for all of us who are not a carlow town club."
Was Davitts v Eire Og not a drawn game?

You're right about MLR, best GAA club in the county by a distance. Hurling will always be no. 1 but they are continuing to produce seriously good footballers too.

Onion Breath (Carlow) - Posts: 1710 - 08/12/2025 13:49:22    2647483

Link

Replying To CARPS:  "Ditching the split season in Carlow will kill the hurling clubs in Carlow Town, Naomh Brid and Burren Rangers... all of whom have made big strides in recent years. It will also destroy any chance of a hurling revival in the north of the county. And it will affect football in the south. MLR beat Eire Og this year. St Mullins beat O'Hanrahans."
I think it's a stretch to call SM a dual club. They enter football only as an after thought once hurling is not interfered with. They have a Kilkenny like attitude to football. No underage football at all at any age and they don't enter the football league only playing championship football.

Onion Breath (Carlow) - Posts: 1710 - 08/12/2025 13:52:13    2647484

Link

Replying To CARPS:  "I spoke to a Wexfordman last night, and he told me that Rathnure resumed playing football (after a long break) when Wexford introduced the split season. Reaching the Junior B final in 2023.

And guess what? As soon as the county board abandoned that wonderful system, they gave it up again.

Which just serves to prove my point. The only way to develop both codes properly is a split season.

It will be a travesty if our county board makes the same mistake as Wexford."
I'm inclined to agree. The split season is the best option for Carlow still. Otherwise hurling will die back whereas now it's growing. And I also think on balance it's better that hurling goers first.

Is there actually a proposal to change this though? When is the county convention?

Onion Breath (Carlow) - Posts: 1710 - 08/12/2025 13:55:12    2647487

Link

Replying To Onion Breath:  "Was Davitts v Eire Og not a drawn game?

You're right about MLR, best GAA club in the county by a distance. Hurling will always be no. 1 but they are continuing to produce seriously good footballers too."
Yes it was Onion. Sorry, got my words mixed up. Meant that it felt like we beat them.

DolmenDave (Carlow) - Posts: 45 - 08/12/2025 15:38:45    2647505

Link

Would it not benefit hurling more to go second? Let the footballers play their football and then they've be able to focus on hurling. For example, Eire Og players might not commit to hurling during the summer because they'd be training and playing challenge football games, but if football was completely finished, they'd have a free run at hurling.
I understand some people might complain about about the weather and playing conditions but the same could be said for both codes.

Repeat1944 (Carlow) - Posts: 13 - 08/12/2025 15:54:11    2647509

Link

Replying To Repeat1944:  "Would it not benefit hurling more to go second? Let the footballers play their football and then they've be able to focus on hurling. For example, Eire Og players might not commit to hurling during the summer because they'd be training and playing challenge football games, but if football was completely finished, they'd have a free run at hurling.
I understand some people might complain about about the weather and playing conditions but the same could be said for both codes."
I think they should rotate it.

CARPS (Carlow) - Posts: 995 - 08/12/2025 17:46:40    2647531

Link

Replying To Repeat1944:  "Would it not benefit hurling more to go second? Let the footballers play their football and then they've be able to focus on hurling. For example, Eire Og players might not commit to hurling during the summer because they'd be training and playing challenge football games, but if football was completely finished, they'd have a free run at hurling.
I understand some people might complain about about the weather and playing conditions but the same could be said for both codes."
That's an argument alright for football to go first, but I think a stronger argument is that it's more likely that as soon as the football would be over for most, say by late August, lads would be more inclined to go playing soccer (and in some cases rugby) which will be starting back then, rather than then go play hurling.

Hurling in summer time is a more attractive game than hurling in Autumn and winter on wet pitches, and reality is in most parts of the county football is the no. 1 game and if the football championship is on lads will generally commit to it over soccer. So to grow hurling I think it's better that hurling has no competition in mid summer for maybe next 5-10 years. That's a key for me to getting lads to commit to hurling and to help the dual and newer hurling clubs to get more established.

No question football loses out a bit by coming second but not as much as hurling would lose if only starting in September.

Onion Breath (Carlow) - Posts: 1710 - 08/12/2025 17:50:47    2647533

Link

Replying To DolmenDave:  "Impressive win for MLR over Davitts today at 20s. I have to say, we were on high after beating Eire Og last week so a bit shell shocked. Granted Eire Og were definitely missing players but I thought we deserved the draw,if not the win. Eire Og had a young minor 16 year old at corner back who was excellent, a definite stand out on their first 15, and another young minor forward who came on as sub, who along with the normal Quinlan genius were the ones that MLR will need to look out for. Eire Og backs are much better than their forwards on last week's display but they will need to be because I have to say MLR, yet again at U20s football look outstanding. We were out battled on all levels today. What a job they have done with that club with both codes at all ages. Eire Og are supposedly the marque carlow club. But are they ? It's a friend's club in there. It's a whos who. Who you know. The rest of us are just trying to survive but MLR is proper community club at both codes. And it shows. And as a non MLR person I congratulate them for their hard work and as it showed today, the results they keep getting at all age levels and codes. It's a great gaa story in our small county and they deserve all the credit they get. A ray of hope for all of us who are not a carlow town club."
Dave it's very clear from your posts since you've joined you're an Eire Og man, not sure why you're trying to pass off as a Davitts man here?

Agreed though about MLR, their ability to turn out players in both codes should be admired

SofaSupporter (Carlow) - Posts: 17 - 08/12/2025 21:23:33    2647557

Link

Replying To SofaSupporter:  "Dave it's very clear from your posts since you've joined you're an Eire Og man, not sure why you're trying to pass off as a Davitts man here?

Agreed though about MLR, their ability to turn out players in both codes should be admired"
I am not an Eire Og man or originally a Davitts man either. As you can see by some of my original posts, I'm actually a Ballon man. Not sure what your issue is, I gave Eire og, Davitts and MLR their flowers in my post. Wasn't denegrading anyone

DolmenDave (Carlow) - Posts: 45 - 09/12/2025 12:55:26    2647627

Link

Replying To DolmenDave:  "I am not an Eire Og man or originally a Davitts man either. As you can see by some of my original posts, I'm actually a Ballon man. Not sure what your issue is, I gave Eire og, Davitts and MLR their flowers in my post. Wasn't denegrading anyone"
Well if you're not an eire og man you've a strange obsession with them. In the visible posts you've mentioned ballon once referring to them as though you've no affiliation with them and this is the first time mentioning davitts. More likely an Eire og man who isn't happy with something in the club but rather give out here.

Good win for ballon Sunday anyway.

SofaSupporter (Carlow) - Posts: 17 - 09/12/2025 13:54:02    2647651

Link

Replying To SofaSupporter:  "Well if you're not an eire og man you've a strange obsession with them. In the visible posts you've mentioned ballon once referring to them as though you've no affiliation with them and this is the first time mentioning davitts. More likely an Eire og man who isn't happy with something in the club but rather give out here.

Good win for ballon Sunday anyway."
You couldn't be more wrong. If anything I'm jealous of who they have in Tach Asca as I said above. If it an argument you want Sofa, you are barking up the rong tree. Here on this forum like all of you just chatting about carlow gaa trying to be informative and join in because I enjoy all aspects of the gaa and enjoying everyone else view points. It that simple

DolmenDave (Carlow) - Posts: 45 - 09/12/2025 15:07:58    2647666

Link