Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Galway Hurling thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Replying To Overdahill:  "Aaah we're back. easy know the winter is in when this starts up. why don't you tell us which of those players shouldn't be on the panel?

Of the Bridge players, I presume you're not talking about Ryan, Lee or Niland. Evan Niland saw a lot more action under previous managements and TJ Brennan has been in since Shane O'Neills time so no bias there.

Trayers and Daithi are mainstays, Dan Loftus again one of the best corner backs in the club championship this year. Sean Linnane has been around for donkeys years and imo has probably seen his best days with Galway pass, but 50/50 call if he's worth a spot. Cillian Whelan is 22 and I'd have him on the panel, you might disagree but hardly egregious.

Meelick eyrecourt is Fleming, well worth a place and close to being a starter.

Don't think there was any Pearases player on the panel last year. Jonah Donnelan called in maybe? What's the issue there?"
I heard they spread net wide last few weeks.
Craughwell have had 1 for last 10 years, 2 last year, 5 in at moment.
A lot of U20's called in.
Loughrea and Tommies will probably get extra lads in.
At end of day, need best 15 out in best positions to match the Limericks of the world.

WesternSeaBoard (Galway) - Posts: 156 - 16/11/2026 10:52:24    2700515

Link

Replying To WesternSeaBoard:  "I heard they spread net wide last few weeks.
Craughwell have had 1 for last 10 years, 2 last year, 5 in at moment.
A lot of U20's called in.
Loughrea and Tommies will probably get extra lads in.
At end of day, need best 15 out in best positions to match the Limericks of the world."
How many lads would be called in at this time of year I wonder? If you have 5 called in from a team where no forward scored from play in a county semi final quite a few I'd imagine!

MoroonMan (Galway) - Posts: 105 - 16/11/2026 13:28:03    2700532

Link

Replying To MoroonMan:  "How many lads would be called in at this time of year I wonder? If you have 5 called in from a team where no forward scored from play in a county semi final quite a few I'd imagine!"
From what I hear there is three Craughwell, one adrahan, one cappataggle, one castlegar and one cappy

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 8 - 17/11/2026 12:38:54    2700585

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "From what I hear there is three Craughwell, one adrahan, one cappataggle, one castlegar and one cappy"
Here is a toned-down version of the Galway hurling post. It keeps your core argument-that management is leaning too heavily on young U20s and overlooking proven club players from teams like Loughrea-while removing the personal digs at selectors, clubmates, and individual young players so it reads as constructive criticism and passes HoganStand moderation easily:

It is well past time that the Galway senior hurling management took a closer look at how the panel is being selected.

Right now, there is a clear bias towards familiar faces and recent U20 graduates:

A heavy proportion of the squad is drawn directly from management's own clubs, with Clarinbridge and Turloughmore making up ten spots between them, alongside further representation from Eyrecourt, Pearses, and Cappataggle.

Meanwhile, management has opted to bring through a wave of young U20s while overlooking seasoned hurlers who have consistently proven themselves at senior club level.

It is no surprise that lighter, less experienced players struggle to impose themselves against physical, battle-hardened outfits like Limerick, where the likes of Gearóid Hegarty, Kyle Hayes, Dan Morrissey, Cian Lynch, Tom Morrissey, Aaron Gillane, Shane O'Brien, and William O'Donoghue set the standard.

Management needs to put more stock in what is happening on the ground in the Galway senior club championship rather than relying so heavily on the underage pathway. Loughrea-the standout club side in the county over the last few years after completing three-in-a-row-only have two potential starters in the mix. Players like Jamie Ryan, arguably the top club hurler in Galway this season, have barely been given a fair look-in.

Truth be told, it is still the experienced core-Pádraic and Cathal Mannion, Daithí Burke, Conor Whelan, and Conor Cooney-carrying this side. Unless management starts integrating proven, physically ready club performers now, Galway hurling will face a steep drop-off once that generation steps away.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 8 - 17/11/2026 12:53:06    2700588

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "From what I hear there is three Craughwell, one adrahan, one cappataggle, one castlegar and one cappy"
Tom Monaghan and who else? Tiernan Leen & Howley? Ciaran a bit young yet. Think he has two years left at U-20 I think and didn't make the team this year

MoroonMan (Galway) - Posts: 105 - 17/11/2026 14:22:52    2700596

Link

In reality it make no real difference who they bring in I know they got 2 final this year but only for they play in Leinster which is very poor they not get anywhere near it , every year Galway are talked up but in history of gaa they have won 5 all irelands and one manger won 3 of them ,,

Kickitout (Galway) - Posts: 1194 - 17/11/2026 14:54:38    2700601

Link

Replying To MoroonMan:  "Tom Monaghan and who else? Tiernan Leen & Howley? Ciaran a bit young yet. Think he has two years left at U-20 I think and didn't make the team this year"
Craughwell score 2pts from play in a County Semi Final and the reward is to bring that many into a County panel??
How is there no fair play towards Loughrea players.
Yes we were blessed with 3/4 excellent young players last year and that was an exception but other than them players the rest of the u20 players were bang average.

Watchthepost (Dublin) - Posts: 20 - 17/11/2026 16:38:52    2700620

Link

Replying To Watchthepost:  "Craughwell score 2pts from play in a County Semi Final and the reward is to bring that many into a County panel??
How is there no fair play towards Loughrea players.
Yes we were blessed with 3/4 excellent young players last year and that was an exception but other than them players the rest of the u20 players were bang average."
It's not the final panel though. These early season panels often have larger numbers. Loughrea are in an All Ireland series so won't have anyone called in until they win it or are knocked out.They had 6 players called in last year, one declined and only 3 made the panel.

MoroonMan (Galway) - Posts: 105 - 17/11/2026 17:53:32    2700628

Link

Replying To MoroonMan:  "Tom Monaghan and who else? Tiernan Leen & Howley? Ciaran a bit young yet. Think he has two years left at U-20 I think and didn't make the team this year"
From what I heard around place the two leens are in tiernan and ciaran, ryan howley, greg thomas, Jonah donnelnan, donnacha campbell, ronan murphy, think a few more u20s (donoghue likes to pick a few from u20s winning team each year), one younger lad from sarsfields forget his name.

From what I'm hearing around the place, the two Leens (Tiarnán and Ciarán) are in, along with Ryan Howley, Greg Thomas, Jonah Donnellan, Donnacha Campbell, Ronan Murphy, and a young lad from Sarsfields whose name escapes me. There are probably a few more U20s in the mix too, as Micheál Donoghue usually brings through a couple from the U20 setup every year.

It's hard to fathom how he is holding onto certain players who had poor club campaigns and didn't even make the matchday 26 all year, while letting go of a few very experienced senior players who started games over the past 12 months and were regulars in the 26. Hard to make sense of it.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 8 - 17/11/2026 22:24:24    2700644

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "From what I heard around place the two leens are in tiernan and ciaran, ryan howley, greg thomas, Jonah donnelnan, donnacha campbell, ronan murphy, think a few more u20s (donoghue likes to pick a few from u20s winning team each year), one younger lad from sarsfields forget his name.

From what I'm hearing around the place, the two Leens (Tiarnán and Ciarán) are in, along with Ryan Howley, Greg Thomas, Jonah Donnellan, Donnacha Campbell, Ronan Murphy, and a young lad from Sarsfields whose name escapes me. There are probably a few more U20s in the mix too, as Micheál Donoghue usually brings through a couple from the U20 setup every year.

It's hard to fathom how he is holding onto certain players who had poor club campaigns and didn't even make the matchday 26 all year, while letting go of a few very experienced senior players who started games over the past 12 months and were regulars in the 26. Hard to make sense of it."
Who are the experienced players he let go who started games?

MoroonMan (Galway) - Posts: 105 - 18/11/2026 10:13:36    2700660

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "From what I heard around place the two leens are in tiernan and ciaran, ryan howley, greg thomas, Jonah donnelnan, donnacha campbell, ronan murphy, think a few more u20s (donoghue likes to pick a few from u20s winning team each year), one younger lad from sarsfields forget his name.

From what I'm hearing around the place, the two Leens (Tiarnán and Ciarán) are in, along with Ryan Howley, Greg Thomas, Jonah Donnellan, Donnacha Campbell, Ronan Murphy, and a young lad from Sarsfields whose name escapes me. There are probably a few more U20s in the mix too, as Micheál Donoghue usually brings through a couple from the U20 setup every year.

It's hard to fathom how he is holding onto certain players who had poor club campaigns and didn't even make the matchday 26 all year, while letting go of a few very experienced senior players who started games over the past 12 months and were regulars in the 26. Hard to make sense of it."
Not hard to fathom at all. The rebuild must go on. That 2025 outfit made good strides, but they're still a transitional looking side that needs to offload the rest of their 'oulads' in the next 1-3 seasons, and then determine how good/great they're going to be, going forward.

Pope_Benedict (Galway) - Posts: 4939 - 18/11/2026 10:31:12    2700662

Link

Replying To MoroonMan:  "Who are the experienced players he let go who started games?"
From what I hear, Evan Niland, Declan McLaughlin, Brian Concannon, and John Cooney have been dropped. It's hard to grasp why McLaughlin and Concannon were let go when they are regularly in the matchday 26. Concannon was injured for part of this year, which Donghue never disclosed I gather-he came back and came on in the semi-final, before breaking his foot in training the Friday before the All-Ireland final. Both he and McLaughlin were named on the 26 for the All-Ireland. It's hard to fathom, especially with Concannon being such a serious goal threat; in my opinion, he has been one of the best players around Galway over the last few years at grabbing a goal when needed. When fully fit, himself alongside Jason Rabbitte would be a serious danger for any full-back line.

Conntribunesh (Galway) - Posts: 8 - 18/11/2026 13:00:50    2700678

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "From what I hear, Evan Niland, Declan McLaughlin, Brian Concannon, and John Cooney have been dropped. It's hard to grasp why McLaughlin and Concannon were let go when they are regularly in the matchday 26. Concannon was injured for part of this year, which Donghue never disclosed I gather-he came back and came on in the semi-final, before breaking his foot in training the Friday before the All-Ireland final. Both he and McLaughlin were named on the 26 for the All-Ireland. It's hard to fathom, especially with Concannon being such a serious goal threat; in my opinion, he has been one of the best players around Galway over the last few years at grabbing a goal when needed. When fully fit, himself alongside Jason Rabbitte would be a serious danger for any full-back line."
MD is probably fed up of Brian's life outside of hurling
Feel sorry for Declan McLaughlin

Tough on Evan, but what has he done in recent years

Cooney cant have any complaints

GalwaysFinest (Galway) - Posts: 243 - 18/11/2026 15:50:40    2700696

Link

Replying To Conntribunesh:  "From what I hear, Evan Niland, Declan McLaughlin, Brian Concannon, and John Cooney have been dropped. It's hard to grasp why McLaughlin and Concannon were let go when they are regularly in the matchday 26. Concannon was injured for part of this year, which Donghue never disclosed I gather-he came back and came on in the semi-final, before breaking his foot in training the Friday before the All-Ireland final. Both he and McLaughlin were named on the 26 for the All-Ireland. It's hard to fathom, especially with Concannon being such a serious goal threat; in my opinion, he has been one of the best players around Galway over the last few years at grabbing a goal when needed. When fully fit, himself alongside Jason Rabbitte would be a serious danger for any full-back line."
Is it a case of a manager throwing his weight around or cutting off his nose to spite his face.
I heard there are also u20 players brought into the panel who were dropped from the first 15 at u20 level or started the All Ireland and replaced after been taken to the cleaners. How can they impact at Senior level.
Copycat tactics more like from management. There are better stronger Club players i.e. Joseph Mooney

Watchthepost (Dublin) - Posts: 20 - 18/11/2026 15:56:43    2700698

Link

Has anyone from Intermediate been called in?

ColmFlaherty (Galway) - Posts: 254 - 18/11/2026 16:18:20    2700702

Link