National Forum

New Fermanagh Manager

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To thewayiseeit:  "The Pete McGrath departure has been handled dreadfully by the County board. Why did they sanction his extension for 2018 without engaging with the players and understanding what the issues were and ironing them if possible before making the appointment. Undue haste ...... Pete has been poorly treated however why is no one asking the questions as to why if everything was rosy with him in charge, why have so many players left the panel. There will always be retirements but what about the good young players like James Allen, James McMahon, Tom Clarke and Ciaran Corrigan to name but a few. . . . . . Dom for manager .......Are you serious ? Have you all got short memories ?. Time to look at some new blood ....... What about Kieran Donnelly with his experience with Omagh CBS , Cavan Gaels and latterly Scotstown or Nigel Seaney who did a fanatstic job in managing Trillick to a county title. Open the eyes lads ."
Typical outsider that knows little about either Pete McGrath or Dom Corrigan. Ignore.

gaalltheway (Fermanagh) - Posts: 806 - 18/07/2017 18:05:57    2018835

Link

Replying To thewayiseeit:  "The Pete McGrath departure has been handled dreadfully by the County board. Why did they sanction his extension for 2018 without engaging with the players and understanding what the issues were and ironing them if possible before making the appointment. Undue haste ...... Pete has been poorly treated however why is no one asking the questions as to why if everything was rosy with him in charge, why have so many players left the panel. There will always be retirements but what about the good young players like James Allen, James McMahon, Tom Clarke and Ciaran Corrigan to name but a few. . . . . . Dom for manager .......Are you serious ? Have you all got short memories ?. Time to look at some new blood ....... What about Kieran Donnelly with his experience with Omagh CBS , Cavan Gaels and latterly Scotstown or Nigel Seaney who did a fanatstic job in managing Trillick to a county title. Open the eyes lads ."
Ah someone who remembers his last stint and that it wasn't all rosey.

gotmilk (Fermanagh) - Posts: 4971 - 18/07/2017 18:10:27    2018838

Link

I would have serious concerns about Dom. Also added issue of two sons in the squad! Was Ciaran Donnelly not in with Canavan? Do you not remember how that ended! Nigel seeney defin a good shout! However the final say will rest with the players or rather the 5 or 6 vocal ones!!!

Molaise (Fermanagh) - Posts: 96 - 18/07/2017 18:42:22    2018853

Link

Molaise the vote was 21 to 9 in favour of a new manager not 5 or 6 players as you suggest!
Regardless of some shortcomings, Dom stands out as the best man to get Fermanagh out of the mess left by McGrath. Yourself and gotmilk are a bit like macca999 as you sit on the fence and won't name a prospective manager for the vacancy but rather you lot enjoy making unwarranted criticism of any suggestions.
Meanwhile, how can McGrath rubbish the Fermanagh players in the Belfast Telegraph by saying that they are misguided and wrong. How the hell can he say they are wrong when he doesn't know the future outcome under any new manager?

Coa_gael (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1185 - 18/07/2017 20:20:04    2018908

Link

Replying To Coa_gael:  "Molaise the vote was 21 to 9 in favour of a new manager not 5 or 6 players as you suggest!
Regardless of some shortcomings, Dom stands out as the best man to get Fermanagh out of the mess left by McGrath. Yourself and gotmilk are a bit like macca999 as you sit on the fence and won't name a prospective manager for the vacancy but rather you lot enjoy making unwarranted criticism of any suggestions.
Meanwhile, how can McGrath rubbish the Fermanagh players in the Belfast Telegraph by saying that they are misguided and wrong. How the hell can he say they are wrong when he doesn't know the future outcome under any new manager?"
I'm off the fence and sayin Oisin mcconville. Great things with cross, currently in with lapis hurlers. I'd imagine he wouldn't mind a role closer to home.

gotmilk (Fermanagh) - Posts: 4971 - 18/07/2017 20:29:30    2018915

Link

Replying To Coa_gael:  "Molaise the vote was 21 to 9 in favour of a new manager not 5 or 6 players as you suggest!
Regardless of some shortcomings, Dom stands out as the best man to get Fermanagh out of the mess left by McGrath. Yourself and gotmilk are a bit like macca999 as you sit on the fence and won't name a prospective manager for the vacancy but rather you lot enjoy making unwarranted criticism of any suggestions.
Meanwhile, how can McGrath rubbish the Fermanagh players in the Belfast Telegraph by saying that they are misguided and wrong. How the hell can he say they are wrong when he doesn't know the future outcome under any new manager?"
It well known that 5 or 6 players lead the heave!!!
As I stated doesn't matter who posters want or who county board want as manager. The players will now decide or if the rumour mill is to be believed they have already informed the county board who they want!!

Molaise (Fermanagh) - Posts: 96 - 18/07/2017 21:16:04    2018941

Link

Oh oh it getting hot in here...ease of Molaise or it will be handbags at 10 paces... lol...stick to your table quizzes E as you know little about the internals of the county footballing scene...and Dave your McConville suggestion is a rare one considering the guy's lack of inter county management experience...Dom is the man that's best placed to harness the best our players have to offer...and what's more he will pick up players previously ignored by the ex-manager.

TurnipHead. (Fermanagh) - Posts: 253 - 18/07/2017 22:07:02    2018966

Link

The current stories surrounding the county team are doing nobody any favours,the county board,the players or Pete McGrath.
Few things noted from situation and sideline
1. Bad communication from county board not to have liaised with players or taken some time to review season before re-appointing McGrath last week
2. Pete McGrath owes Fermanagh nothing,in his time he achieved as much as anyone could have with the resources available,until this year Fermanagh were highly competitive,gave 100% every time
3. This year team hit with retirements and lads travelling,this was underestimated and being realistic was going to be hard to build on previous years given lack of underage success
4. Players lacked hungers and desire shown in the previous 3 years(games against Kildare and Meath),looked as if lost interest under management....no excuse when representing your county

Good article in telegraph today,find it totally unfair that players were questioning the introduction of two subs in the Monaghan games(Jones,Courtney,Beacom and Keenan were players brought on that day)shows lack of respect for management,some should be more concerned with own lack of performance in 2017 Players getting too much power and this will surely lead to fallout among players in accusing some of not putting the work in.
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sport/gaa/misguided-erne-stars-have-got-it-all-wrong-says-ex-fermanagh-boss-pete-mcgrath-35940435.html

From watching games this year id agree that was probably time for change to re-energise the panel,as only very few managers nowdays can continually inspire the same players to put in commitment required at inter-county level for 5 years or more. This whole debacle wont help in attracting in new manager,especially if hoping to attain outsider.

Talk of Corrigan gathering momentum,although with two sons on the panel id say its less than ideal(would this have been influence in voting for McGrath to leave). Not easy situation as Mark Harte found out playing for Tyrone number of years ago.
Just when though the 2017 couldnt get any worse it does. Lets hope thats end of the publicity on this,county board starts planning ahead to future and get set-up in time for club championship

macca999 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1170 - 18/07/2017 22:40:34    2018984

Link

Replying To TurnipHead.:  "Oh oh it getting hot in here...ease of Molaise or it will be handbags at 10 paces... lol...stick to your table quizzes E as you know little about the internals of the county footballing scene...and Dave your McConville suggestion is a rare one considering the guy's lack of inter county management experience...Dom is the man that's best placed to harness the best our players have to offer...and what's more he will pick up players previously ignored by the ex-manager."
Who in the name of christ is Dave?

When was the last time Dom managed a county? 2006? Remind me again how that fared out for him. Remind me how he did with Fermanagh? Why would McConville not be fit to work with all the players in the county. He has no baggage with any of them. He has an excellent cv in club football management. He's worked with some of the biggest professional sporting organisations.

What's Dom done? Won a couple of school competitions and a few county titles.

gotmilk (Fermanagh) - Posts: 4971 - 18/07/2017 23:04:56    2018995

Link

Replying To gotmilk:  "Who in the name of christ is Dave?

When was the last time Dom managed a county? 2006? Remind me again how that fared out for him. Remind me how he did with Fermanagh? Why would McConville not be fit to work with all the players in the county. He has no baggage with any of them. He has an excellent cv in club football management. He's worked with some of the biggest professional sporting organisations.

What's Dom done? Won a couple of school competitions and a few county titles."
The idea of Dom taking over makes no sense whats so ever!!! I'm told however that he not the number one choice of the players. They are reported to have handed a list of three men to the county chairman and Dom their third choice!

Molaise (Fermanagh) - Posts: 96 - 19/07/2017 09:19:00    2019082

Link

Replying To Molaise:  "The idea of Dom taking over makes no sense whats so ever!!! I'm told however that he not the number one choice of the players. They are reported to have handed a list of three men to the county chairman and Dom their third choice!"
Sorry sir or madam you are talking rubbish. No such instructions were either given or would they be followed by the county board. The recruitment process doesn't work that way as it has to follow GAA protocol guidance.

It was disappointing that Pete McGrath has chosen to use his privileged position to reveal details of private discussions in respect the concerns of the majority of our county players. I hope his decision will not come back to haunt him as it may make any prospective county board or club wary of him given his insensitive reaction.

At this stage, not one of the Fermanagh players have broken rank and I have great admiration for their reserved position. Media outlets may use the crisis to feed the thirst of their followers but the Fermanagh people are much more resilient and will rise about this current cheap publicity.

The Fermanagh team should be cherished and respected and into the future under a new manager they will move on and hopefully achieve greater success and maybe a much sought after Ulster Championship title.

gaalltheway (Fermanagh) - Posts: 806 - 19/07/2017 10:31:46    2019120

Link

Replying To gaalltheway:  "Sorry sir or madam you are talking rubbish. No such instructions were either given or would they be followed by the county board. The recruitment process doesn't work that way as it has to follow GAA protocol guidance.

It was disappointing that Pete McGrath has chosen to use his privileged position to reveal details of private discussions in respect the concerns of the majority of our county players. I hope his decision will not come back to haunt him as it may make any prospective county board or club wary of him given his insensitive reaction.

At this stage, not one of the Fermanagh players have broken rank and I have great admiration for their reserved position. Media outlets may use the crisis to feed the thirst of their followers but the Fermanagh people are much more resilient and will rise about this current cheap publicity.

The Fermanagh team should be cherished and respected and into the future under a new manager they will move on and hopefully achieve greater success and maybe a much sought after Ulster Championship title."
Lol!!! Follow GAA protocol!!!!! Lol!!!! Lol!!!!!!! McGrath was reappointed in accordance with GAA protocol! The players then went against this.

My source is correct. The players have submitted a list to the county chairman. The reason they not talking to press is they know they wrong and cant defend what they have done. If they sure they right let's hear them!!!

Molaise (Fermanagh) - Posts: 96 - 19/07/2017 12:08:53    2019198

Link

And so the Molaise rant still goes on...and on...so you do not seem to get it that 21 players to 9 favoured change...voted by intelligent adults many of whom are from the legal, teaching and financial sectors... that's what's called democracy... as for reappointment the procedure is simpler does not carry require the same amount tick-boxes as there would be for the appointment of a new manager...however I think on hindsight that the players should have been consulted before confirming McGrath's continuing management...I agree with gaalltheway that McGrath's disclosure of internal matters was less than honourable...the players and I know many of them personally are gentleman and deserve better press than they are getting...so let this be the end of this rant against our galant lads in green and white!

TurnipHead. (Fermanagh) - Posts: 253 - 19/07/2017 13:57:47    2019282

Link

Interesting quote from the Irish independent

There wasn't too much wrong less than 23 months ago when they were still involved in championship football, marching through the qualifiers and lauding McGrath's impact.

But when the milk turned sour, there was little time for introspection. Point your forefinger, and you'll find that three point back at you. It's up to the players to explain their stance now.

Molaise (Fermanagh) - Posts: 96 - 19/07/2017 18:27:25    2019478

Link

As an outsider with an interest in Fermanagh football, as I lived for some years in the county, I'm disappointed that Fermanagh finds itself in the difficult situation it is now in. There are no winners when this happens and the character of manager, management and players is often much maligned. Hopefully the County Board can find some young up-and-coming manager quickly so that everyone can move on quickly before relationships become very soured.
I see that one of your regular posters takes exception to outsiders like myself posting about Fermanagh matters but 'outsiders' post on most County sites because of some connection to the county.

neverright (Roscommon) - Posts: 1648 - 19/07/2017 20:01:19    2019516

Link

I think there silence says a lot about them (the player). Some of the rumours doing the rounds about McGrath's treatments of players is quite damming of the man. He has spoken to numerous outlets about the incident since the heave yet they haven't disclosed anything. They don't want to tarnish his reputation but he's willing to do it to the players. That for me says everything.
gotmilk (Fermanagh) - Posts:4343 - 19/07/2017 13:38:17


If McGrath had to step down gracefully, most people would have had some respect for him. His onslaught of player criticism and private changing room revelations from his perspective really diminishes the standing of the man. I know it takes two to tango but the players have collectively remained reserved and thereby have made McGrath look even more of a pathetic rejected manager.

ekn_teacher (Fermanagh) - Posts: 272 - 20/07/2017 00:07:40    2019683

Link

Nothing against these lads but Jones came on against Monaghan, after missing the whole year through injury. R.Corrigan out for 10 months and gets played against Armagh. Then Pete had the cheek to say there was no preferential treatment. And then like usual with everything, he goes STRAIGHT to the media. Might have suited him better to listen to players concerns rather than drafting up his next Newspaper article!

shotgun (Fermanagh) - Posts: 130 - 20/07/2017 00:46:42    2019693

Link

Looking at reports that Tyrone lash out a decade of the rosary before their matches, maybe Fermanagh should look at Fr Brian Darcy as manager? With such a small pool of players to pick from and limited fire power up front, maybe some divine intervention is the best hope?

local (Fermanagh) - Posts: 154 - 20/07/2017 10:15:32    2019785

Link

It's becoming quite obvious that Pete McGrath having had his ego damaged is digging an ever bigger hole for himself by his deliberate media crusade against the players concerned by giving his selective take as to why the Fermanagh team rejected him. Meanwhile, the real truth remains untold by the players and their silence is not only diplomatic but a clever, welcomed and praiseworthy position to adapt.

Now to the important stuff, who is likely to take the vacant manager's position? Those in the frame so far include Dom Corrigan, Ciaran Donnelly, Sean Cavanagh (retiring this year from county football), former manager John Maughan, Oisin McConville and there's the want-to-be county manager Aidan Gilroy or even Charlie Mulgrew who gets a recall mention on social media! But what about the talented Derrygonnelly club manager, Martin Greene? He comes with a pretty healthy success in club football. Then there are the former county footballers and Allstar winners Peter McGinnity (with significant managerial experience), Barry Owens and Martin McGrath all capable of giving the team a fresh start. So who is it to be? macca999 and gotmilk any thoughts?

The_Rat (Fermanagh) - Posts: 54 - 20/07/2017 11:12:59    2019836

Link

My money is on an Owens and McGrath partnership. Both recent retirees, sound commentators in newsprint, know Fermanagh players from their current involvement in Club games, seem committed and are Fermanagh men to the core. Can anybody come up with a better solution?

hairyhorse (Fermanagh) - Posts: 94 - 20/07/2017 11:41:44    2019855

Link