Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Roscommon GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Replying To The_analyser:  "Excellent in gaining and retaining possession Salthill-Knocknacarra was. Far less errors on the ball than Brigids. Shooting efficiency will be all that will disappoint Salthill-Knocknacarra tonight.

At full time players and management celebrated like they won Connacht but need to settle down and refocus for the trip to Castlebar."
Given the manner in which they won it, with the last second dramatics anyone can be forgiven for celebrating emotionally.
They'll get nothing easy against Castlebar and will have to deal with the expectation of being favourites, unlike today where they were coming in as underdogs.
They have enough experienced players and leaders in the squad and All-Ireland club winners in their management team to get them ready for that. Whether they'll win or not is another matter, but they have a right shot at it.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3177 - 15/11/2026 20:44:54    2700480

Link

Replying To Rossies4sam:  "Why is it widely accepted Armagh and westmeath deserve an all star due to a provincial title but we dont get one beating both Mayo and Galway to one?"
Both Armagh and Westmeath both made progress after winning their provincial crowns. Roscommon flopped in the AI series

Jack L (None) - Posts: 3249 - 15/11/2026 21:46:40    2700485

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "Given the manner in which they won it, with the last second dramatics anyone can be forgiven for celebrating emotionally.
They'll get nothing easy against Castlebar and will have to deal with the expectation of being favourites, unlike today where they were coming in as underdogs.
They have enough experienced players and leaders in the squad and All-Ireland club winners in their management team to get them ready for that. Whether they'll win or not is another matter, but they have a right shot at it."
Agree with you and if the last free for brigids goes over similar scenes would've been seen two very good teams going at it
Good luck in the final

rossy15 (Roscommon) - Posts: 706 - 15/11/2026 22:23:13    2700488

Link

Brigids 1 to ten ( counting hand as 10) excellent at club level even though Carroll was well shook in goals today near the end of the match
But hand aside little pace to scare at the highest level.
Boc his bro, Nugent all nice forwards tap over handy points when not under pressure but there not elite forwards none of them going to score 4 or 5 two pointers against a decent team as in a all Ireland contender
None of them hardly get a goal chance never mind 2 versus a elite side.
Brigids are just missing a 10 points player no matter how big the game player to win the all Ireland maybe 1 of the 3 will step up maybe.

OhtobeARossie (Roscommon) - Posts: 1839 - 15/11/2026 23:37:34    2700495

Link

It was four years ago, in 2022, when Moycullen beat Strokestown in extra time in Tuam. A Galway club hasn't beaten a Roscommon club since then, so look, today was always going to happen eventually. There's very little between the clubs in the two counties, but the manner in which it happened was extremely disappointing.

I see people saying Salthill could have won by more. Respectfully, I don't see it. Most of the shots they missed were really low and straight into Carroll's hands. Brigids could have had a larger lead going into half-time, using a similar argument. But look, regardless, they got the job done. Best of luck to Salthill going forward. Some Galway fans said the same to Brigids last year, so it's only right to return the favour. There was a lot of heart, hunger and desire in Salthill, which you have to respect.

As for Brigids, they were so flat in the second half. Even in the first half, the amount of silly wides they kicked could have made the gap even larger. It just wasn't like them, and it ultimately cost them in the end.

What I loved about Brigids during their 2023 and 2025 runs was that they never panicked in games. They played quick, attacking football and were extremely balanced between control and attack. Even against St Mary's last week, they were absolutely clinical. Why did they allow Salthill to get as much oxygen as they did?

In the second half, they looked spooked and just didn't handle the situation well at all. The midfield was poor, and they were completely dominated by Salthill.

Their defence, without Pearse Frost following his injury the previous day, was unfortunately just bleak. Going forward, they were so slow and almost Davy Burke-like in their approach.

I'm just not sure about Conor Carroll at times. I know he could have won it, but why was he on the free in the first place after missing frees in the club final against Dingle? The midfield wasn't great, and they have to take their share of the blame, but the kick-outs were poor and all over the place, especially in the second half.

Brigids have also played a lot of games in The Hyde during previous campaigns and perhaps just weren't accustomed to the Salthill wind at all.

I apologise if I'm being harsh on them, but if there was ever a Roscommon team I thought could win an All-Ireland, it was this one. The standards they have set over the previous few seasons have been so high.

To win two in a row for the first time in a long time in Roscommon, I thought they would be a serious outfit in the All-Ireland series. The problem for next year is that Pearses aren't going anywhere. Boyle weren't bad, Strokestown might improve, and you would surely expect Clann and the Gaels to get their act together. Moycullen will desperately want to get out of Galway next year, so Brigids might have missed another precious opportunity.

Look, Cunningham had a bad first year, but he came so close in his second. The current management will have to be seriously questioned about what happened today and how Brigids dropped off so dramatically in the second half.

Éire Óg are our last light. Hopefully, they get plenty of support. Brigids could have done with a bit of that support in the second half!

Roscommon had a solid, good year, but they clearly need the Brigids lads in the long term if they're going to get to Croke Park. They didn't really get any fair chances at all, because the team selected was playing so well. Why would you practically bring them in at that stage from dowds perspective ? Having all the options at the start mighten be too bad

From an inter-county perspective, rather than a club perspective, this could be a blessing in disguise. I would have slight worries about Division 1, with Cork and Meath away. The two teams that came up are games you would have liked to have at home. However, a bit more depth in the squad and hopefully the lads can take out their frustration on the pitch. That could ultimately help Roscommon.

It's sickening for Brigids. They have given us a lot of brilliant days, and today wasn't one of them. I don't know when, and I don't know where, but hopefully they're back in a final in January at some point in the future.

Gavlar (Roscommon) - Posts: 29 - 16/11/2026 00:29:08    2700496

Link

Replying To tommyc:  "Hopefully it is. against St Mary's (Sligo) I could see Brigids seemed to go short on kick outs too much and it looked like they were deliberately avoiding their midfield area. To me looked like a weakness. And so it proved as Salthill devoured Brigids on their kick out in the second half . Perhaps there a cruel irony on who missed the last minute free. Hard luck Brigids"
St. Brigid's starting midfield pairing when they reached the All-Ireland final last January was Eddie Nolan and Shane Cunnane. As another poster rightly pointed out pre-match, both have been starved of game time this year, and getting just 40 and 20 minutes respectively in that game highlighted a clear lack of match sharpness making it only natural that they were weaker in that sector.

There was also a touch of irony in the Salthill goalkeeper pulling off that match-winning save in the dying seconds, considering Salthill-Knocknacarra isn't even his original club.

Ultimately, while Brigid's were well below their usual standards after the break, failing to build more than a six-point cushion at half-time with the breeze will be their biggest regret. Converting just 6 of their 13 first-half shots

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 4119 - 16/11/2026 01:24:01    2700497

Link

Replying To Gaa_lover:  "St. Brigid's starting midfield pairing when they reached the All-Ireland final last January was Eddie Nolan and Shane Cunnane. As another poster rightly pointed out pre-match, both have been starved of game time this year, and getting just 40 and 20 minutes respectively in that game highlighted a clear lack of match sharpness making it only natural that they were weaker in that sector.

There was also a touch of irony in the Salthill goalkeeper pulling off that match-winning save in the dying seconds, considering Salthill-Knocknacarra isn't even his original club.

Ultimately, while Brigid's were well below their usual standards after the break, failing to build more than a six-point cushion at half-time with the breeze will be their biggest regret. Converting just 6 of their 13 first-half shots"
Ah now you can't talk
About irony considering Brigids own keeper. I don't think this was a massive shock. Most lads I spoke with thought it was on the cards with the two missing marking backs and an absent midfield pairing all year. Salthills county players are all some of Galway's best too. I hope they go on and win it.

I'd never begrudge a Roscommon club but it is a massive boost for Mark Dowd to have all his players available now. Brigids won't be going away and in all honesty will be stronger in 2027 and a strong contender for the all Ireland again.

Ros2013 (Roscommon) - Posts: 689 - 16/11/2026 10:04:29    2700508

Link

Replying To Gaa_lover:  "St. Brigid's starting midfield pairing when they reached the All-Ireland final last January was Eddie Nolan and Shane Cunnane. As another poster rightly pointed out pre-match, both have been starved of game time this year, and getting just 40 and 20 minutes respectively in that game highlighted a clear lack of match sharpness making it only natural that they were weaker in that sector.

There was also a touch of irony in the Salthill goalkeeper pulling off that match-winning save in the dying seconds, considering Salthill-Knocknacarra isn't even his original club.

Ultimately, while Brigid's were well below their usual standards after the break, failing to build more than a six-point cushion at half-time with the breeze will be their biggest regret. Converting just 6 of their 13 first-half shots"
Ironic I'm assuming because Brigid's isn't Carroll's original club either. The rest of Salthill's team are all homegrown, in fairness to them, which wouldn't have been the case in the past.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3177 - 16/11/2026 11:02:52    2700516

Link

Replying To Gavlar:  "It was four years ago, in 2022, when Moycullen beat Strokestown in extra time in Tuam. A Galway club hasn't beaten a Roscommon club since then, so look, today was always going to happen eventually. There's very little between the clubs in the two counties, but the manner in which it happened was extremely disappointing.

I see people saying Salthill could have won by more. Respectfully, I don't see it. Most of the shots they missed were really low and straight into Carroll's hands. Brigids could have had a larger lead going into half-time, using a similar argument. But look, regardless, they got the job done. Best of luck to Salthill going forward. Some Galway fans said the same to Brigids last year, so it's only right to return the favour. There was a lot of heart, hunger and desire in Salthill, which you have to respect.

As for Brigids, they were so flat in the second half. Even in the first half, the amount of silly wides they kicked could have made the gap even larger. It just wasn't like them, and it ultimately cost them in the end.

What I loved about Brigids during their 2023 and 2025 runs was that they never panicked in games. They played quick, attacking football and were extremely balanced between control and attack. Even against St Mary's last week, they were absolutely clinical. Why did they allow Salthill to get as much oxygen as they did?

In the second half, they looked spooked and just didn't handle the situation well at all. The midfield was poor, and they were completely dominated by Salthill.

Their defence, without Pearse Frost following his injury the previous day, was unfortunately just bleak. Going forward, they were so slow and almost Davy Burke-like in their approach.

I'm just not sure about Conor Carroll at times. I know he could have won it, but why was he on the free in the first place after missing frees in the club final against Dingle? The midfield wasn't great, and they have to take their share of the blame, but the kick-outs were poor and all over the place, especially in the second half.

Brigids have also played a lot of games in The Hyde during previous campaigns and perhaps just weren't accustomed to the Salthill wind at all.

I apologise if I'm being harsh on them, but if there was ever a Roscommon team I thought could win an All-Ireland, it was this one. The standards they have set over the previous few seasons have been so high.

To win two in a row for the first time in a long time in Roscommon, I thought they would be a serious outfit in the All-Ireland series. The problem for next year is that Pearses aren't going anywhere. Boyle weren't bad, Strokestown might improve, and you would surely expect Clann and the Gaels to get their act together. Moycullen will desperately want to get out of Galway next year, so Brigids might have missed another precious opportunity.

Look, Cunningham had a bad first year, but he came so close in his second. The current management will have to be seriously questioned about what happened today and how Brigids dropped off so dramatically in the second half.

Éire Óg are our last light. Hopefully, they get plenty of support. Brigids could have done with a bit of that support in the second half!

Roscommon had a solid, good year, but they clearly need the Brigids lads in the long term if they're going to get to Croke Park. They didn't really get any fair chances at all, because the team selected was playing so well. Why would you practically bring them in at that stage from dowds perspective ? Having all the options at the start mighten be too bad

From an inter-county perspective, rather than a club perspective, this could be a blessing in disguise. I would have slight worries about Division 1, with Cork and Meath away. The two teams that came up are games you would have liked to have at home. However, a bit more depth in the squad and hopefully the lads can take out their frustration on the pitch. That could ultimately help Roscommon.

It's sickening for Brigids. They have given us a lot of brilliant days, and today wasn't one of them. I don't know when, and I don't know where, but hopefully they're back in a final in January at some point in the future."
Some of the SK shots which dropped short should have been tap overs, very poor misses. Not to mention a good few missed goal chances, one off the crossbar and a goal handed to Mr Hand.
I thought Salthill were the better team overall. They dominated the middle and pressured Brigid's up the pitch. Brigid's have plenty quality and could have snatched it in the end.
I don't think anyone else could have kicked that free at the end apart from Carroll. Out on the sideline, against the wind, it was over 50m out. You're not curling that over with a left foot against that wind. Had to be off the ground. Not sure if Cunnane would have the range for it. It was a brilliant strike to be honest. Very unlucky to come off the post.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3177 - 16/11/2026 11:13:23    2700518

Link

Replying To Gavlar:  "It was four years ago, in 2022, when Moycullen beat Strokestown in extra time in Tuam. A Galway club hasn't beaten a Roscommon club since then, so look, today was always going to happen eventually. There's very little between the clubs in the two counties, but the manner in which it happened was extremely disappointing.

I see people saying Salthill could have won by more. Respectfully, I don't see it. Most of the shots they missed were really low and straight into Carroll's hands. Brigids could have had a larger lead going into half-time, using a similar argument. But look, regardless, they got the job done. Best of luck to Salthill going forward. Some Galway fans said the same to Brigids last year, so it's only right to return the favour. There was a lot of heart, hunger and desire in Salthill, which you have to respect.

As for Brigids, they were so flat in the second half. Even in the first half, the amount of silly wides they kicked could have made the gap even larger. It just wasn't like them, and it ultimately cost them in the end.

What I loved about Brigids during their 2023 and 2025 runs was that they never panicked in games. They played quick, attacking football and were extremely balanced between control and attack. Even against St Mary's last week, they were absolutely clinical. Why did they allow Salthill to get as much oxygen as they did?

In the second half, they looked spooked and just didn't handle the situation well at all. The midfield was poor, and they were completely dominated by Salthill.

Their defence, without Pearse Frost following his injury the previous day, was unfortunately just bleak. Going forward, they were so slow and almost Davy Burke-like in their approach.

I'm just not sure about Conor Carroll at times. I know he could have won it, but why was he on the free in the first place after missing frees in the club final against Dingle? The midfield wasn't great, and they have to take their share of the blame, but the kick-outs were poor and all over the place, especially in the second half.

Brigids have also played a lot of games in The Hyde during previous campaigns and perhaps just weren't accustomed to the Salthill wind at all.

I apologise if I'm being harsh on them, but if there was ever a Roscommon team I thought could win an All-Ireland, it was this one. The standards they have set over the previous few seasons have been so high.

To win two in a row for the first time in a long time in Roscommon, I thought they would be a serious outfit in the All-Ireland series. The problem for next year is that Pearses aren't going anywhere. Boyle weren't bad, Strokestown might improve, and you would surely expect Clann and the Gaels to get their act together. Moycullen will desperately want to get out of Galway next year, so Brigids might have missed another precious opportunity.

Look, Cunningham had a bad first year, but he came so close in his second. The current management will have to be seriously questioned about what happened today and how Brigids dropped off so dramatically in the second half.

Éire Óg are our last light. Hopefully, they get plenty of support. Brigids could have done with a bit of that support in the second half!

Roscommon had a solid, good year, but they clearly need the Brigids lads in the long term if they're going to get to Croke Park. They didn't really get any fair chances at all, because the team selected was playing so well. Why would you practically bring them in at that stage from dowds perspective ? Having all the options at the start mighten be too bad

From an inter-county perspective, rather than a club perspective, this could be a blessing in disguise. I would have slight worries about Division 1, with Cork and Meath away. The two teams that came up are games you would have liked to have at home. However, a bit more depth in the squad and hopefully the lads can take out their frustration on the pitch. That could ultimately help Roscommon.

It's sickening for Brigids. They have given us a lot of brilliant days, and today wasn't one of them. I don't know when, and I don't know where, but hopefully they're back in a final in January at some point in the future."
Hard luck to Brigids but it is an incredibly tough road to try and make it back to a club All Ireland. This could be major captain hindsight but you could also say the first time this year they've come up against a midfield with the quality of a John Maher added with Shane Cunnanes lack of game time. They've a great age profile so they'll be around for a while and might be all the fresher next year.

FullOfPorter (Roscommon) - Posts: 654 - 16/11/2026 11:53:32    2700521

Link

Replying To Ros2013:  "Ah now you can't talk
About irony considering Brigids own keeper. I don't think this was a massive shock. Most lads I spoke with thought it was on the cards with the two missing marking backs and an absent midfield pairing all year. Salthills county players are all some of Galway's best too. I hope they go on and win it.

I'd never begrudge a Roscommon club but it is a massive boost for Mark Dowd to have all his players available now. Brigids won't be going away and in all honesty will be stronger in 2027 and a strong contender for the all Ireland again."
Read back on the Tommyc post I'm replying too. "Perhaps there a cruel irony on who missed the last minute free" who do you think he's talking about?

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 4119 - 16/11/2026 13:27:56    2700531

Link

Replying To Jack L:  "Both Armagh and Westmeath both made progress after winning their provincial crowns. Roscommon flopped in the AI series"
As a Roscommon man, I have no complaint. We were terrible in Clones against an ordinary Monaghan team. Let's move on to next year. We'll have the Brigid's players from the off and Roscommon should aim for a long hot Summer in 2027. We have plenty of good footballers. Mayo showed the way this year after we had hammered them in April.

endgame (Roscommon) - Posts: 2804 - 16/11/2026 13:29:43    2700533

Link

A combined 48 shots yielding just 22 scores tells the true story of yesterday's contest. Among the starting forwards, only Ben O'Carroll, Rob Finnerty (0-4 each), and Brian Derwin (0-3) managed to meaningfully trouble the scoreboard; on an afternoon defined by misfiring attacks, it felt entirely fitting that a defender would ultimately decide the tie with a long-range strike.

I have seen several neutrals and match reports today praising the game as a 'good contest.' While it was undoubtedly competitive and went right down to the wire, it was a far cry from the genuinely high-calibre spectacles I have witnessed this year, such as Oran versus Castlerea or Boyle against Pádraig Pearses.


Ultimately, Pearse Stadium played a major role in dragging down the overall standard. Any winter fixtures involving Galway sides with home advantage ought to be staged in Tuam Stadium which almost certainly would have been the case had anyone other than Salthill-Knocknacarra been involved yesterday.

Regardless, best of luck to them in the provincial final, while St. Brigid's can now enjoy a well earned rest after two gruelling All-Ireland final runs in the past three years clearly took their toll

The_analyser (Roscommon) - Posts: 4548 - 16/11/2026 15:19:32    2700544

Link