Minor Championship

Killan Gaels bt Lavey

Ramor bt Cavan Gaels by 1 point

Both league finalists knocked out in the QF.

jacknoff (Cavan) - Posts: 163 - 02/08/2010 21:06:52    733495

Minor Championship

Killan Gaels bt Lavey

Ramor bt Cavan Gaels by 1 point

Both league finalists knocked out in the QF.

jacknoff (Cavan) - Posts: 163 - 02/08/2010 21:10:24    733502

eire og celtic drumgoon/cootehill beat kilinkere
eire og strong team but got a man sent of

tommymc123 (Cavan) - Posts: 12 - 02/08/2010 21:36:59    733558

Yes, killann beat lavey by a few, if lavey could convert their possession into scores, killann were in trouble.
Ramor beat the gaels by two, i as a neutral at the game had the score gaels 1-6, ramor 0-11. Of course, gaels being above every body kicked up a fuss about the game being a draw, or some stupid malark like that, but ramor deservedly won.
Gowna and ballyhaise will be a tight game, if ballyhaise get their act together they have the players to win. Corglass gaels and st.joesephs will be a tough one to call, corglass are slight favourites and should win by 4-7 points. Any results from division two?

galoping gazele (None) - Posts: 174 - 03/08/2010 08:40:24    733631

The referee has changed his mind about the score he gave after the Cavan Gaels Ramor game. Apparently he's saying its a draw now!! Someone got to him. It's a shame and a disgrace. Where will it end? Are officials in this county above adhering to the GAA constitution?
Maybe Louth should take their case up in this county..

cailin deas (Cavan) - Posts: 68 - 03/08/2010 12:41:50    733944

was at the game as a nutural thought it was a draw

r6 (Cavan) - Posts: 12 - 03/08/2010 12:52:34    733968

Ramor won the game 11 to 1-6! Its a disgrace if it is replayed! Ramor were the better team on the day and typically the Gaels cannot take a defeat! but after all the Gaels should be the favourites for the shield now??

theviper (Cavan) - Posts: 41 - 03/08/2010 13:37:42    734078

The referee has changed his mind about the score he gave after the Cavan Gaels Ramor game. Apparently he's saying its a draw now!! Someone got to him. It's a shame and a disgrace. Where will it end? Are officials in this county above adhering to the GAA constitution?
Maybe Louth should take their case up in this county..
cailin deas , 03/08/2010 at 12:41


Has anyone said it has to be replayed, did the ref not say the score at the end of the match. Why are you attacking the county board if they have not even made a comment on this issue.
If the ref gives in the score as a draw well that is it and whatever has to be done will be done I am sure. How can the County Bord be responsible for this. Tell me was there a video of this match well if in doubt why not watch the footage if there was.???

The Quiet Man (Cavan) - Posts: 4602 - 03/08/2010 13:58:31    734132

Calm down Seanorinn,
I am not attacking the county board at all, there are some excellent people in there. You are right, it is nothing to do with the county board, and referees are only human, they can make mistakes, and teams can lose out, but that's life! Even with TV cameras it doesn't guarantee against error. And I don't know if there was a video. I just went to watch a good game, and I'll be going again this evening to another minor match, and I hope to see a good game again! And on a positive note, lets hope the county will rise up and work on a plan for the senior team for the future. Kildare proved solid hard work and committtment and determination pays off!

cailin deas (Cavan) - Posts: 68 - 03/08/2010 15:29:11    734348

if its replayed its a bloody disgrace.It wouldnt be done for any other team in the county.If the gaels had to have put up a scoreboard this wouldnt have happened.All in all been at the game and keeping the score i would have Ramor down as 1 point winners.

Tonto1 (Cavan) - Posts: 26 - 03/08/2010 16:53:19    734521

Yes Tonto1 i agree along with the whole county on this. Ramor won end of issue. Its because its cavan gaels, booo hooo. Even after the game the gaels players(fair play to them) took their defeat well and had no arguments with the result, it was just the hierarchy of the club, their officials, one in particular that cast a blanket of doubt in the refs mind through his disgusting verbal abuse. Fair play to emo for his handling of the situation.
Moving on, anybody give me a time for the gowna ballyhaise game?

galoping gazele (None) - Posts: 174 - 03/08/2010 17:05:09    734546

Was at the Gaels v Ramor match last night which properly ended 1-7 to 10pts. The ref released after the game that he had marked a score down to Ramor which should of been given to the gaels. Sure it wasnt till one of the Ramor players asked the ref is there extra time when he told them they had one by two points. Ramor where as suprised as anyone when they were told that they had won. Game must be replayed.

Sergeant (Cavan) - Posts: 100 - 03/08/2010 19:03:43    734692

galoping gazele
County: All
Posts: 84

734546
Yes Tonto1 i agree along with the whole county on this. Ramor won end of issue. Its because its cavan gaels, booo hooo. Even after the game the gaels players(fair play to them) took their defeat well and had no arguments with the result, it was just the hierarchy of the club, their officials, one in particular that cast a blanket of doubt in the refs mind.
Moving on, anybody give me a time for the gowna ballyhaise game?


You clearly weren't at the game. The Gaels players certainly did not accept the result. Everyone in the ground knew it finished a draw apart from the ref. Sure it wasn't until the ref announced the score until the Ramor lads started celebrating. Thought it was also bad form by the Ramor officials who pretended that they weren't keeping the score once they realised that ref awarded them the match. Just proves even more that the game ended level.

Sergeant (Cavan) - Posts: 100 - 03/08/2010 19:10:24    734699

Corglass gaels were bet by 3 points by st josephs 2-13 to 1-13 very good game and best team won

Mr_Big (Cavan) - Posts: 75 - 03/08/2010 21:47:40    734927

Sergeant

I clearly was at the game.The ramor players knew they had won and started cheering.The gaels players dropped to the ground when the final whilstle went which indicated that they knew they had been defeated.From your post it plain to see that your are indeed a gaels man.It was the senior member of the gaels club who protest after the game and by senior i mean those who dont play football and our sore losers and would probably switch to drumalee if drumalee became the strongest team in the town.

Tonto1 (Cavan) - Posts: 26 - 03/08/2010 21:50:57    734938

I was at the game seargant. Look, im not getting involved i just went to see a good game, came on this to voice my opinion thats all. Ramor won, they play the winners of gowna ballyhaise and thats the end of the issue as far as i can see. Its because its cavan gaels. Did the meath louth game go to a replay? Was that human error too? As i said i had ramor winning by 2 myself and cant see where i might have made a mistake in my score keeping. Good game at least for the neutrals. I was suprised at st.joes winning last night. Corglass looked very strong and i fancied them, st.joes will be very hard stopped and their game with killann(i think, correct me if im wrong) sholud be a good game.

galoping gazele (None) - Posts: 174 - 04/08/2010 08:44:24    734993

I was also at the game.Firstly it was the best game i have been to all weekend and i was at 5 senior and 3 minor matches.I kept the scores as did some people around me.Ihad it 7 points to 1-2 to ramor at half time and Cavan Gaels won the second half 5 points to 4.This means it was 11points to ramor and 1-7 to Cavan Gaels which 2 other people had around me aswell.Where i have a problem is that on my way out from the ground these people that also told me Ramor had won were abusing the ref and saying it was now a draw .The Ramor manager very wisely took his players up to the far end of the feild to do a warmdown and let the croud and cavangaels players go of the pitch as did the st joes manager in their game with Corglass gaels when tensions were running high.Have lessonns not being learned from the leinster final .The Ref had the wrong score but Ramor Won by 1.It was also a good game with St Joes and Corglass with st joes losing by 8 points at one stage in the first half and coming back to win by 3.Lavey had an awful lot of possesion in their game with killan but could not score and were punished when killan got a lucky goal and went on to win by 6.

goldenball (Cavan) - Posts: 27 - 04/08/2010 08:50:42    734996

Goldenball,
I was at the Corglass Gaels game too, enjoyed it have to say. Was speaking to a few that were at Gaels /Ramor game. All agree that Ramor won it on that scoreline-0-11 t0 1-7, even though ref said Ramor won by 2. What worries me is that if the game is taken from Ramor and a replay is forced, what is to stop any club in the future going to the ref after a tight game and complaining. This is an extremely dangerous situation. My own club were involved in a situation similar at an U-16 game years ago, there was a debate over a point, many thought it wide including the umpire, but th ref gave the score, and we lost by a point. We were upset, but the final score stood.

cailin deas (Cavan) - Posts: 68 - 04/08/2010 10:58:12    735173

someone post the scorers please in the ramor v gaels game and i will decide the final score.
it shouldn't be too difficult to determine who won . there is a right score and a wrong score.
obviously the players themselves know the score. each one of them knows how much they scored so lets be having you.

s goldrick (Cavan) - Posts: 5522 - 04/08/2010 11:55:33    735297

who is kilaan gaels playin in semi

minorkid (Cavan) - Posts: 14 - 04/08/2010 12:04:40    735336