National Forum

All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship 2025

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Kilkenny are a hurling legend and that is why they lead with titles. However even though a close game this team is not near their standard. Out muscled and turned over. Out goaled which is their trade mark. Out desired that once they got ahead of you went for the jugular and killed you off. Out coached as it was three goals later before they
realized what Tipp were doing. Pulling the best full back in the game out the field and sending players in around the back.
The rest of Leinster spend too much time admiring them with the exception of Wexford when they have the horses no fear. The Munster teams respect them but not in awe of them.
Incidentally the miss use of cards goes on. One player dismissed when his stick made minor contact after he had passed out his opponent and making zero intent to hit him. The other was a slap down on the head of all places and considered an accident. Beggars belief.

Canuck (Waterford) - Posts: 3125 - 06/07/2025 20:50:08    2623988

Link

Getting the score wrong by RTE and inside the stadium is a major error . Kilkenny would be fully justified in looking for a replay .

loughree (Westmeath) - Posts: 77 - 06/07/2025 20:54:50    2623990

Link

Replying To Onion Breath:  "Was the final score on RTE correct? I thought there was 2 points in it at the end?"
Hoganstand results page showing a 3 point win currently......Tipp 4-21 KK 0-30

Pope_Benedict (Galway) - Posts: 4294 - 06/07/2025 20:56:08    2623991

Link

Even with Limerick and Clare out of it, we still end up with a second Munster Final. That the state of hurling nowadays.

foreveryoung (USA) - Posts: 2328 - 06/07/2025 21:01:35    2623992

Link

Replying To CTGAA10:  "Not sure but if he does miss out it's going to be very tough on the young fella..the fact it's a 2nd sending off might be a problem..2nd yellow was probably harsh but he had no hope of getting ball and made it easy for ref..I hope he gets to play unit..
A bigger question for me is how they missed the deegan incident,specially linesman who was next to it..for me that was a red not a 2nd yellow..
If scoreboard in croke park said it was a 3 point lead then an explanation is needed..kk had chances to put ball over but were going for what they thought was needed,a goal..if kk had got a goal and won by a point according to official score then how was it going to be explained??
Official score given as 4-20 to 30 points.."
Absolute amateur hour at the end with the wrong score line.

The Cats had plenty of time and opportunity to get 2x 1pt scores, to draw the game.
Of course appearing to be losing by 3pts would have affected their mindset with how they attacked near the end.
I would be fuming if I were them.

Not acceptable.

As for the Deegan incident - straight Red all day long and right in front of the official - bonkers.

Fionn (Dublin) - Posts: 4424 - 06/07/2025 21:03:00    2623993

Link

Replying To CTGAA10:  "Not sure but if he does miss out it's going to be very tough on the young fella..the fact it's a 2nd sending off might be a problem..2nd yellow was probably harsh but he had no hope of getting ball and made it easy for ref..I hope he gets to play unit..
A bigger question for me is how they missed the deegan incident,specially linesman who was next to it..for me that was a red not a 2nd yellow..
If scoreboard in croke park said it was a 3 point lead then an explanation is needed..kk had chances to put ball over but were going for what they thought was needed,a goal..if kk had got a goal and won by a point according to official score then how was it going to be explained??
Official score given as 4-20 to 30 points.."
I wasn't paying attention to the scoreboard on RTE coverage and couldnt understand why Kilkenny were trying to work the ball in and not taking the point chances they had around the 72nd minute mark, with plenty of time to get another . If the scoreboard was wrong in Croke park too it definetely impacted KK's last attacks.

JimB1991 (Donegal) - Posts: 103 - 06/07/2025 21:03:22    2623994

Link

Well done Tipp - some result for them. 4-20 to 0-30
To score 4 goals v Kilkenny and play for 16 minutes, including injury time, with only 14 men was some effort.
The Cats had goal chances but after scoring 30pts, will feel they left this behind them.
Hope McCarthy gets to play in the Final but having been sent off for a 2nd time, it might be difficult....

Tipp looking for their 29th All Ireland Hurling title and first since 2019.
Cork looking for their 31st All Ireland and first for the Rebels in 2 decades.
The Cats of Kilkenny out in front on 36 titles.

I still think it is Cork's All Ireland to lose tbh.
No offence to Tipp but I really hope Cork win it.

Fionn (Dublin) - Posts: 4424 - 06/07/2025 21:21:52    2623997

Link

Replying To loughree:  "Getting the score wrong by RTE and inside the stadium is a major error . Kilkenny would be fully justified in looking for a replay ."
How? Referee not responsible for RTE and scoreboard operator making howlers. Umpire clearly signaled a wide.

Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2244 - 06/07/2025 21:47:32    2624005

Link

Replying To Yadse:  "Delighted to see Tipp do it and they deserved it (although the scoreboard controversy was unfortunate and might have been the difference)
I think they will give Cork a much tougher game than Kilkenny would and all the pressure is going to be on Cork.

Look it, this is not a dig on Leinster hurling, but regardless of whether or not Munster teams are better it's not helping Leinster teams and especially Kilkenny to come into the AI series without the kind tough games that Munster teams are getting.
And the gap is growing

Regardless of who wins the AI next year Munster is going to be a tougher than ever."
Dont agree with massive gap betwern munster and leinster only for the unforced errors kk made to give away the goals i actually thought kk were the better team.Would they have bet Cork not a hope will Tipp not a hope either im afraid.

Tiger1 (Wexford) - Posts: 406 - 06/07/2025 21:52:20    2624006

Link

Replying To Tirchonaill1:  "Brilliant win for Tipp, I wasn't much of a hurling fan but I think I am now, great final in store."
A 1st ever Cork v Tipp All Ireland Senior Hurling Final.
Gonna be some build up to it.

Even though I was thrilled with the 1/4 Final result, I reckon the Limerick lads will be kicking themselves still, about not making the Final.

It is going to take a hell of an effort from Tipp to get close to Cork in a couple of weeks imo.
But stranger things have happened, so you never know.

Fionn (Dublin) - Posts: 4424 - 06/07/2025 21:56:57    2624007

Link

Look the score board thing is terrible and I might have a little leaning towards the cats (family) but the goal was worthy of winning any game. Kilkenny had an extra man when they should not. If Kilkenny won should it be replayed because it should have been 14 on 14..Move on the best team on the day won.

Canuck (Waterford) - Posts: 3125 - 06/07/2025 22:00:32    2624009

Link

I be my usual broken record. All cards should be reviewed. Especially red. Now they will get up on their hind legs and deny this young Tipp player a chance to play in the final. We have seen the ref against us giving a warning in his little black book to a player on a yellow. It's called flavour of the day.

Canuck (Waterford) - Posts: 3125 - 06/07/2025 22:06:09    2624010

Link

Replying To Yadse:  "Delighted to see Tipp do it and they deserved it (although the scoreboard controversy was unfortunate and might have been the difference)
I think they will give Cork a much tougher game than Kilkenny would and all the pressure is going to be on Cork.

Look it, this is not a dig on Leinster hurling, but regardless of whether or not Munster teams are better it's not helping Leinster teams and especially Kilkenny to come into the AI series without the kind tough games that Munster teams are getting.
And the gap is growing

Regardless of who wins the AI next year Munster is going to be a tougher than ever."
Not too sure about that.

Dublin full value for their win over Limerick.

Kilkenny were unlucky today to be honest. In fairness to Tipp goals win games but Kilkenny were probably the better side if not for them panicking and going for goal a little early.

Tipp reminded me of 19 semi final. To their credit found a way to grind out a result against a team that was superior to them.

Doylerwex (Wexford) - Posts: 3815 - 06/07/2025 22:27:18    2624013

Link

Replying To 32_4_1:  "Why can't Cork overturn it? No one on their level in the foreseeable future. Win one All Ireland, and a few will follow!"
Way to early. It's hard to win an all Ireland, even harder to win another. The Cork team of the 00s were amazing and only managed two. It's an outrageous claim to be calling the next decade of hurling.

Doylerwex (Wexford) - Posts: 3815 - 06/07/2025 22:30:16    2624014

Link

Replying To Canuck:  "I be my usual broken record. All cards should be reviewed. Especially red. Now they will get up on their hind legs and deny this young Tipp player a chance to play in the final. We have seen the ref against us giving a warning in his little black book to a player on a yellow. It's called flavour of the day."
Two yellows means no suspension, a rule for the last 30 years

Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2244 - 06/07/2025 22:52:37    2624015

Link

Replying To Doylerwex:  "Not too sure about that.

Dublin full value for their win over Limerick.

Kilkenny were unlucky today to be honest. In fairness to Tipp goals win games but Kilkenny were probably the better side if not for them panicking and going for goal a little early.

Tipp reminded me of 19 semi final. To their credit found a way to grind out a result against a team that was superior to them."
Doylerwex this Kilkenny team are not a patch on teams of the past. Even going back before the last great team. No real big stars other than the 37 year old. They usually have 6 or 7 super stars backed up great players and guys on the bench as good as the great ones. At the end of the day they are the top team in Leinster facing the third team in Munster. A great opportunity for ye and others to match up. Leinster can be equally as competitive as Munster. They were not the best team today and the scoreline flattered them. Coming down the stretch turned over time again. Passes going To Tipp players including the one leading to the winning goal.

Canuck (Waterford) - Posts: 3125 - 06/07/2025 23:07:39    2624018

Link

Unfortunately for the Cats, like Dublin, their body of work hasn't been good enough throughout the year. They beat a very poor Galway team and let them back into the game in the Leinster Final. Lost to Wexford (albeit with a much changed team) Unconvincingly beat Dublin, just, after being a whole 14 points ahead at half time.

I am glad Tipp won because Kilkenny wouldn't have been able for Cork in the final. Tipp Cork will be much more competitive.

mr305 (Galway) - Posts: 67 - 06/07/2025 23:15:30    2624019

Link

Replying To Claretandblue:  "How? Referee not responsible for RTE and scoreboard operator making howlers. Umpire clearly signaled a wide."
The umpire putting his hand up to catch the ball going wide caused the whole confusion… Any one doing that job should know to never go near the ball but just concentrate on the correct signal… This is why I have always called for official referees to be umpiring at county level instead of buddies of the appointed referee…

ForeverBlue2 (Cavan) - Posts: 4237 - 06/07/2025 23:15:58    2624020

Link

Replying To Canuck:  "Look the score board thing is terrible and I might have a little leaning towards the cats (family) but the goal was worthy of winning any game. Kilkenny had an extra man when they should not. If Kilkenny won should it be replayed because it should have been 14 on 14..Move on the best team on the day won."
If Kilkenny had scored a goal at the end - extra time would've been played although KK would have won by 1 point?

CnocÁine (Limerick) - Posts: 8 - 06/07/2025 23:16:55    2624021

Link

Replying To Tiger1:  "Dont agree with massive gap betwern munster and leinster only for the unforced errors kk made to give away the goals i actually thought kk were the better team.Would they have bet Cork not a hope will Tipp not a hope either im afraid."
20 points not a massive enough gap for you!?

The reality is there is one half decent team in Leinster. That is Kilkenny. As a Galway man I am very disappointed to say that. but Galway, Dublin and Wexford are nowhere near good enough. Don't be fooled by Dublin's once in a lifetime performance. They were bet by Kilkenny 16 points in LSHF last year and managed to find themselves 14 points down at half time to the Cats in this years Leinster Round Robin game (although credit for a good comeback to Dublin) Galway (who are as bad a Galway team in manys a year) were cruising in Parnell against the Dubs and 10 points up with 5 mins to go. 2 late goals from Dublin but a gloss on the score line.

The gap is HUGE. Galway didn't come within 10 points of any Munster team this year (League and championship defeats to Tipp)
Cork in the league.
Limerick in the league. all 12 point defeats

And don't tell me we beat Clare. we did. but who didn't beat Clare and their B team in the league this year!

mr305 (Galway) - Posts: 67 - 06/07/2025 23:22:53    2624023

Link