National Forum

All Ireland Club Semi Finals

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To Northsidegaels:  "Ususually such a balanced poster you have let yourself down here badly, the gaoth dobhair goal never should have stood and corofin were just a better all round team. Take off the green and gold glasses and watch again!"
Good man yourself coming on here questioning the colour of the glasses I wear without using a pair yourself to read all my posts. Of course I have a Donegal bias which I am happy to admit but I am not delusional with it. Something u have clearly noted in that u have pointed out my views are usually quite balanced. Where did I suggest that the best team lost? In fact I have reiterated again and again that the best team on the day won. Did I not agree that too many steps were taken after watching back the Gweedore goal a few times including giving my own foot count? It was not something that was glaringly obvious at the game including people I was standing close to which was more of a Corofin bias where I was standing. I completely stand by my comments on Deegan. He was correct to move frees closer if getting lip but being at the game I can sense where their frustration came from. If u want to give me ur address I will polish these glasses of mine before sending them in the post for you. Being a meath man you won't mind the green and yellow tints.

panamasam (Australia) - Posts: 2779 - 17/02/2019 16:25:36    2165885

Link

panamasam is making a fool of himself. 6/7 steps? Can you not count, its 10 steps and very very obvious. Deegan was shocking for both teams, Gweedore were on the receiving end of several soft frees too.

Corofin can play a lot better than that and Croke Park will suit their style of football, it should be a great game between the 2 best club sides in the country.

JDF (Galway) - Posts: 322 - 18/02/2019 11:16:52    2166085

Link

Replying To JDF:  "panamasam is making a fool of himself. 6/7 steps? Can you not count, its 10 steps and very very obvious. Deegan was shocking for both teams, Gweedore were on the receiving end of several soft frees too.

Corofin can play a lot better than that and Croke Park will suit their style of football, it should be a great game between the 2 best club sides in the country."
Post a link of the footage where 10 steps is very very obvious please thank u. I have been using twitter highlights to watch back. But what difference does it make? I don't think I disputed that too many steps were taken whether it is 5, 6, 7 or 10 as u say. What I did say it is that it was not so obvious at the game and there was no feeling of discontent among the Corofin supporters I was close to. The steps only came to my attention here and there has been little about it apart. There is a loose implementation of the rule which is getting exploited. I was watching Sigerson highlights from yesterday and noted the NUIG goal to come as a result of too many steps.

I think in my various posts here I have given fair examples of where Deegan was at time impartial. Alot of which stemmed from frees not given when obvious and resulting lip in his direction which result in a few frees been moved forward. Rightly so too for acts of descent though when a player goes to take a quick free and the ball gets kicked away would this not constitute descent also? I am not the only one to highlight this as it has come up in some of the Donegal media too. But nobody myself included are using this as an excuse as AGAIN THE BEST TEAM WON.

For the record yes I can be sometimes biased towards Donegal but like to think also measured and realistic. My club connection would historically see Gweedore as not so friendly rivals. However I like going to club games and I have enjoyed watching them play much like Kilcar last year. As a result I put club rivalry aside to support Donegal clubs outside of Donegal especially if they play an endearing style of football. But when not directly connected to the club I don't think my views have been delusional or foolish like suggested. To be a fool it would be to suggest that Deegan was at fault for Gweedore's loss. Or not recognise that too many steps were taken. Or not give credit to what is a great Corofin team none of which I am guilty of despite the labels. Also I would be a fool to engage with someone to any great degree who labels in such fashion without really giving much insight themselves. Reading ur reply it comes across as a little dismissive, arrogant and classless.

I would like to wish Corofin all the best in the final but very difficult to really invest when u read the likes of above. Which is a shame given the admiration I would have for the likes of the Farraghers, Ian Burke and the excellent Kieran Burke and Gary Sice.

panamasam (Australia) - Posts: 2779 - 18/02/2019 19:06:29    2166211

Link

Replying To panamasam:  "Post a link of the footage where 10 steps is very very obvious please thank u. I have been using twitter highlights to watch back. But what difference does it make? I don't think I disputed that too many steps were taken whether it is 5, 6, 7 or 10 as u say. What I did say it is that it was not so obvious at the game and there was no feeling of discontent among the Corofin supporters I was close to. The steps only came to my attention here and there has been little about it apart. There is a loose implementation of the rule which is getting exploited. I was watching Sigerson highlights from yesterday and noted the NUIG goal to come as a result of too many steps.

I think in my various posts here I have given fair examples of where Deegan was at time impartial. Alot of which stemmed from frees not given when obvious and resulting lip in his direction which result in a few frees been moved forward. Rightly so too for acts of descent though when a player goes to take a quick free and the ball gets kicked away would this not constitute descent also? I am not the only one to highlight this as it has come up in some of the Donegal media too. But nobody myself included are using this as an excuse as AGAIN THE BEST TEAM WON.

For the record yes I can be sometimes biased towards Donegal but like to think also measured and realistic. My club connection would historically see Gweedore as not so friendly rivals. However I like going to club games and I have enjoyed watching them play much like Kilcar last year. As a result I put club rivalry aside to support Donegal clubs outside of Donegal especially if they play an endearing style of football. But when not directly connected to the club I don't think my views have been delusional or foolish like suggested. To be a fool it would be to suggest that Deegan was at fault for Gweedore's loss. Or not recognise that too many steps were taken. Or not give credit to what is a great Corofin team none of which I am guilty of despite the labels. Also I would be a fool to engage with someone to any great degree who labels in such fashion without really giving much insight themselves. Reading ur reply it comes across as a little dismissive, arrogant and classless.

I would like to wish Corofin all the best in the final but very difficult to really invest when u read the likes of above. Which is a shame given the admiration I would have for the likes of the Farraghers, Ian Burke and the excellent Kieran Burke and Gary Sice."
*Kieran Molloy and Gary Sice

panamasam (Australia) - Posts: 2779 - 18/02/2019 20:01:55    2166216

Link

Replying To panamasam:  "Post a link of the footage where 10 steps is very very obvious please thank u. I have been using twitter highlights to watch back. But what difference does it make? I don't think I disputed that too many steps were taken whether it is 5, 6, 7 or 10 as u say. What I did say it is that it was not so obvious at the game and there was no feeling of discontent among the Corofin supporters I was close to. The steps only came to my attention here and there has been little about it apart. There is a loose implementation of the rule which is getting exploited. I was watching Sigerson highlights from yesterday and noted the NUIG goal to come as a result of too many steps.

I think in my various posts here I have given fair examples of where Deegan was at time impartial. Alot of which stemmed from frees not given when obvious and resulting lip in his direction which result in a few frees been moved forward. Rightly so too for acts of descent though when a player goes to take a quick free and the ball gets kicked away would this not constitute descent also? I am not the only one to highlight this as it has come up in some of the Donegal media too. But nobody myself included are using this as an excuse as AGAIN THE BEST TEAM WON.

For the record yes I can be sometimes biased towards Donegal but like to think also measured and realistic. My club connection would historically see Gweedore as not so friendly rivals. However I like going to club games and I have enjoyed watching them play much like Kilcar last year. As a result I put club rivalry aside to support Donegal clubs outside of Donegal especially if they play an endearing style of football. But when not directly connected to the club I don't think my views have been delusional or foolish like suggested. To be a fool it would be to suggest that Deegan was at fault for Gweedore's loss. Or not recognise that too many steps were taken. Or not give credit to what is a great Corofin team none of which I am guilty of despite the labels. Also I would be a fool to engage with someone to any great degree who labels in such fashion without really giving much insight themselves. Reading ur reply it comes across as a little dismissive, arrogant and classless.

I would like to wish Corofin all the best in the final but very difficult to really invest when u read the likes of above. Which is a shame given the admiration I would have for the likes of the Farraghers, Ian Burke and the excellent Kieran Burke and Gary Sice."
To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link

Soma (UK) - Posts: 2630 - 18/02/2019 20:06:24    2166219

Link

Replying To Soma:  "To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link"
Thank u. Counted 8 there myself. Of course being at the game not I did not have the benefits of commentary. Maybe like most in the crowd at the game the steps were not as noticeable to the Corofin players either. Kieran Molloy pick up off the ground for the first goal? Looks marginal but again something I only noticed with the benefits of replay.

panamasam (Australia) - Posts: 2779 - 18/02/2019 21:15:03    2166234

Link

Replying To panamasam:  "
Replying To Soma:  "To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link"
Thank u. Counted 8 there myself. Of course being at the game not I did not have the benefits of commentary. Maybe like most in the crowd at the game the steps were not as noticeable to the Corofin players either. Kieran Molloy pick up off the ground for the first goal? Looks marginal but again something I only noticed with the benefits of replay."
Molloy clearly gets a foot under it at 31 seconds in the clip. Check out @officialgaa's Tweet: https://twitter.com/officialgaa/status/1096768852770328577?s=09

GDL (Galway) - Posts: 719 - 18/02/2019 22:05:41    2166244

Link

Replying To panamasam:  "
Replying To Soma:  "To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link"
Thank u. Counted 8 there myself. Of course being at the game not I did not have the benefits of commentary. Maybe like most in the crowd at the game the steps were not as noticeable to the Corofin players either. Kieran Molloy pick up off the ground for the first goal? Looks marginal but again something I only noticed with the benefits of replay."
It can be hard to judge but you can say he took at least 8 steps, maybe up to 10 steps. He should have played the ball just as Lundy came in to make the tackle but knew he would probably be dispossessed so just kept running. These things happen, winners accept it and get on with it.
As for Molloy picking the ball off the ground, the view from behind the goal shows he clearly puts his foot under it. link

Soma (UK) - Posts: 2630 - 18/02/2019 22:32:02    2166252

Link

Replying To panamasam:  "
Replying To Soma:  "To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link"
Thank u. Counted 8 there myself. Of course being at the game not I did not have the benefits of commentary. Maybe like most in the crowd at the game the steps were not as noticeable to the Corofin players either. Kieran Molloy pick up off the ground for the first goal? Looks marginal but again something I only noticed with the benefits of replay."
In fairness, Molloy was on the near sideline and had his hands out appealing for steps as the Gaoth Dobhair player was running through. The rest of the players were involved in the action and were obviously more focused on trying to stop him.
The commentary team mentioned the steps straight away as did plenty others. Every reply to RTE tweeting the goal, is in relation to the steps. I counted at least 9.
For Corofin's first goal it's also clear that Molloy put his foot under the ball. It was even hopping a bit.
You gave a fair assessment of the game, and we can leave it at that........ unless anyone wants to talk about David Brady's idiotic tweet. :)

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 2034 - 18/02/2019 23:42:50    2166263

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "
Replying To panamasam:  "[quote=Soma:  "To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link"
Thank u. Counted 8 there myself. Of course being at the game not I did not have the benefits of commentary. Maybe like most in the crowd at the game the steps were not as noticeable to the Corofin players either. Kieran Molloy pick up off the ground for the first goal? Looks marginal but again something I only noticed with the benefits of replay."
In fairness, Molloy was on the near sideline and had his hands out appealing for steps as the Gaoth Dobhair player was running through. The rest of the players were involved in the action and were obviously more focused on trying to stop him.
The commentary team mentioned the steps straight away as did plenty others. Every reply to RTE tweeting the goal, is in relation to the steps. I counted at least 9.
For Corofin's first goal it's also clear that Molloy put his foot under the ball. It was even hopping a bit.
You gave a fair assessment of the game, and we can leave it at that........ unless anyone wants to talk about David Brady's idiotic tweet. :)"]David Brady's tweet, what a nasty attention seeking tweet, Gaoth Dobhair had prepared well, totally insensitive tweet considering the tragedy that befell the area. Fair play to Kevin Cassidy, he really put him in his box. Then what would you expect from a guy who had the cops looking for his stolen car in Dublin one time, when it was where he parked it originally, eh ahh.

Uimhir.a.3. (Galway) - Posts: 409 - 19/02/2019 10:18:06    2166300

Link

Replying To Uimhir.a.3.:  "
Replying To WanPintWin:  "[quote=panamasam:  "[quote=Soma:  "To be fair the commentator spotted the number of steps taken straight away. Fair play to Corofin for not protesting at the time but that is the sign of champions, they know there is no point complaining about things they can't control.
link"
Thank u. Counted 8 there myself. Of course being at the game not I did not have the benefits of commentary. Maybe like most in the crowd at the game the steps were not as noticeable to the Corofin players either. Kieran Molloy pick up off the ground for the first goal? Looks marginal but again something I only noticed with the benefits of replay."
In fairness, Molloy was on the near sideline and had his hands out appealing for steps as the Gaoth Dobhair player was running through. The rest of the players were involved in the action and were obviously more focused on trying to stop him.
The commentary team mentioned the steps straight away as did plenty others. Every reply to RTE tweeting the goal, is in relation to the steps. I counted at least 9.
For Corofin's first goal it's also clear that Molloy put his foot under the ball. It was even hopping a bit.
You gave a fair assessment of the game, and we can leave it at that........ unless anyone wants to talk about David Brady's idiotic tweet. :)"]David Brady's tweet, what a nasty attention seeking tweet, Gaoth Dobhair had prepared well, totally insensitive tweet considering the tragedy that befell the area. Fair play to Kevin Cassidy, he really put him in his box. Then what would you expect from a guy who had the cops looking for his stolen car in Dublin one time, when it was where he parked it originally, eh ahh."]I would have some issues with Cassidy in the past but he nailed this one.

To say that Sunday's result had anything to do with what happened in a pub over two months ago is idiotic in the extreme. What did Brady expect from a club that had just won it's first Ulster title ever? That they be tucked up at 7.30 or maybe having a cup of tea & a sandwich?

If you can't go nuts after a huge win like that then what's the bloody point?

MuckrossHead (Donegal) - Posts: 5028 - 19/02/2019 11:15:16    2166315

Link

Pana think you should hold your hands up now - you got it badly wrong on the 2 key decisions

Was 10 steps and was not picked off the ground

eunans4ever (Donegal) - Posts: 1595 - 19/02/2019 11:28:34    2166320

Link