(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?
tipp11 (Tipperary) - Posts: 353 - 11/07/2018 14:22:15 2120727 Link 2 |
|
What are you talking about?
GreenandRed (Mayo) - Posts: 7335 - 11/07/2018 14:33:13 2120732 Link 2 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means.
GreenandRed (Mayo) - Posts: 7335 - 11/07/2018 14:37:16 2120736 Link 2 |
|
I was talking about Gilroy hinting at an asterisk next to Dublin's recent success. Baloney.
Gavvygavgav (Dublin) - Posts: 382 - 11/07/2018 15:04:01 2120746 Link 1 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative. gormdubhgorm (Dublin) - Posts: 990 - 11/07/2018 15:25:19 2120750 Link 2 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Dublin have played all of their HOME games in Croke Park for nearly 10 years, and Croke Park is in Dublin. I dont see how that dosent point to 'home ground' at this stage NaomhNaille (Donegal) - Posts: 124 - 11/07/2018 16:05:42 2120760 Link 1 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Not confused. Only an idiot waould claim a Dublin venue for a Dublin team is neutral. GreenandRed (Mayo) - Posts: 7335 - 11/07/2018 16:08:02 2120761 Link 2 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Here we go with this Parnell park rubbish again, the last time ye played there in the championship was 2004 against London, it has never been or never will be Dublin's home ground. Nobody was sure who would be in what group for this stage of the competition so no objections were made at Congress. Donegal did recently as it effects them the most and fair play to them for doing so. I'm sure if the 'rules' stated that teams playing Dublin had to have one hand tied behind there back then you wouldn't have a problem with that either. That's the issue the rules are favouring one team over the other 7 at this stage of the competition, but it'll be changed hopefully for next year. KY4SAM2015 (Kerry) - Posts: 898 - 11/07/2018 16:12:08 2120765 Link 1 |
|
Launching the Super 8s with two double headers in Croke Park makes sense in so many ways. Its also a very attractive package for neutral fans over the week-end. Curlew66 (Roscommon) - Posts: 504 - 11/07/2018 16:32:54 2120768 Link 0 |
|
As Eamonn Sweeney put it dubgrugers will always find something to cling onto. I for one hope Dublin play more games away from croke park as I believe it is the venue they are most likely to be caught in. For someone like mcguiness to suggest it will affect there legacy just smacks of bitterness. jacktheDub (Dublin) - Posts: 944 - 11/07/2018 17:32:49 2120781 Link 0 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Not confused. Only an idiot waould claim a Dublin venue for a Dublin team is neutral."]Do you not understand under the GAA rules Croke Park is deemed as a neutral venue Parnell Park is Dublin's home ground. This is ALREADY a known fact - why complain now? I can't put it clearer then that. I can't remember the Dublin hurlers crying about having to play a championship game against Tipp last year in Semple stadium 'The Home of Hurling' Croke Park is GAA HQ/'The Home of football' gormdubhgorm (Dublin) - Posts: 990 - 11/07/2018 17:52:54 2120784 Link 0 |
|
Yeah but even Sweeney drowning in a sea of ignorance did state that Dublin had a huge advantage playing at 'home'. Seemed to used the article as an opportunity to not for the first time have a cheap shot at Donegal which didnt add much to the debate. Both teams are focused on next Saturdays match and the venue will be a non issue next Monday morning. I think the majority of people have moved on by now. Curlew66 (Roscommon) - Posts: 504 - 11/07/2018 17:55:32 2120785 Link 0 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Here we go with this Parnell park rubbish again, the last time ye played there in the championship was 2004 against London, it has never been or never will be Dublin's home ground. Nobody was sure who would be in what group for this stage of the competition so no objections were made at Congress. Donegal did recently as it effects them the most and fair play to them for doing so. I'm sure if the 'rules' stated that teams playing Dublin had to have one hand tied behind there back then you wouldn't have a problem with that either. That's the issue the rules are favouring one team over the other 7 at this stage of the competition, but it'll be changed hopefully for next year."]If there was any problem with it, it should be aired when the fixtures are designed in Congresss. Why are people in GAA so reactionary after the fact? 'The NCT syndrome' - don't get the car fixed fail wait for the problems to show - then fix themselv Again it is already known that Parnell Park is Dublin's home ground. Croke Park is a neutral venue, but the DCB now rent Croke Park. This is not new. Congress at fault. Let's be honest if Dublin played Donegal in Ballybofey twice they would more then likely still win anyway. This is just creating hype for the game and stir interest that is all. Fellas like Jim Mc playing mind games as usual. gormdubhgorm (Dublin) - Posts: 990 - 11/07/2018 18:01:01 2120789 Link 0 |
|
What has JmcG got to be bitter about? The point he was making is that while Dublin may well go on to win 4 or 5 or 6 in a row, people will say "sure look at all the advantages they had" Now you may well disagree with him & fair enough if you do but to call our Jim bitter is hurtful in the extreme & will no doubt be used in the Donegal dressing room as a rallying cry. I'm sure you don't want that on your conscience so I would apologise straight away if I were you. MuckrossHead (Donegal) - Posts: 5028 - 11/07/2018 18:01:40 2120790 Link 1 |
|
Would you rather play the Dubs away in Croke Park or away in Parnell Park? Ask your players that and they'll tell you Croke Park every time. In fact other counties vote for it all the time. Talk to your CB and then come back to us.
Joxer (Dublin) - Posts: 4700 - 11/07/2018 18:18:50 2120792 Link 0 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Here we go with this Parnell park rubbish again, the last time ye played there in the championship was 2004 against London, it has never been or never will be Dublin's home ground. Nobody was sure who would be in what group for this stage of the competition so no objections were made at Congress. Donegal did recently as it effects them the most and fair play to them for doing so. I'm sure if the 'rules' stated that teams playing Dublin had to have one hand tied behind there back then you wouldn't have a problem with that either. That's the issue the rules are favouring one team over the other 7 at this stage of the competition, but it'll be changed hopefully for next year."]If there was any problem with it, it should be aired when the fixtures are designed in Congresss. Why are people in GAA so reactionary after the fact? 'The NCT syndrome' - don't get the car fixed fail wait for the problems to show - then fix themselv Again it is already known that Parnell Park is Dublin's home ground. Croke Park is a neutral venue, but the DCB now rent Croke Park. This is not new. Congress at fault. Let's be honest if Dublin played Donegal in Ballybofey twice they would more then likely still win anyway. This is just creating hype for the game and stir interest that is all. Fellas like Jim Mc playing mind games as usual."]Im not going to argue with anyone who thinks Parnell park is Dublins home ground as its pointless. If ye did play twice in Ballybofey and won by a million points it doesnt matter, the structure of the competition isnt fair on three teams in the group with one team having an extra home game. Anyway it should be rectified for next year as i said. KY4SAM2015 (Kerry) - Posts: 898 - 11/07/2018 18:31:47 2120794 Link 1 |
|
So if tipp decide clonmel or nenagh is their home ground but too small to hold matches and we play every single game in semple stadium could we claim it as neutral?"]Of course you can. But then you not inderstand the term 'neutral' as it seems some Dublin posters also struggle with that term. I know rightly Tipp11 you definitely know what neutral means."]I think it is you that is confused Croke Park is GAA HQ it is a neutral venue which happens to be situated in Dublin. Dublin's home ground is Parnell Park it always has been. The Dublin footballers have not had a 'home' game in Parnell Park since 2009. They used in Parnell Park prior to the advent of the 'Spring Series'. All of this inofmation should not be a surprise to you nor should be a surprise to anyone who was at the GAA congress. Dublin hurlers played Tipp in semple last year in the championship, I had no problem with it was pre-arranged, the KK v Waterford game was on after it. Big crowd great atmosphere. In fact Dublin played Kerry in Semple when Croke Park was being redeveloped by in 2001 it was pre-arranged there was no problem with it. Why the issue now? All these greivence's you have could have been aired at Congress by delegates. But not ONE delegate put thier hand up and questioned it. Congress at fault not Dublin's. This is just Donegal led by the likes of Jim McGuinness trying to create a belated story, to whip up a 'them v us' narrative."]Here we go with this Parnell park rubbish again, the last time ye played there in the championship was 2004 against London, it has never been or never will be Dublin's home ground. Nobody was sure who would be in what group for this stage of the competition so no objections were made at Congress. Donegal did recently as it effects them the most and fair play to them for doing so. I'm sure if the 'rules' stated that teams playing Dublin had to have one hand tied behind there back then you wouldn't have a problem with that either. That's the issue the rules are favouring one team over the other 7 at this stage of the competition, but it'll be changed hopefully for next year."]If there was any problem with it, it should be aired when the fixtures are designed in Congresss. Why are people in GAA so reactionary after the fact? 'The NCT syndrome' - don't get the car fixed fail wait for the problems to show - then fix themselv Again it is already known that Parnell Park is Dublin's home ground. Croke Park is a neutral venue, but the DCB now rent Croke Park. This is not new. Congress at fault. Let's be honest if Dublin played Donegal in Ballybofey twice they would more then likely still win anyway. This is just creating hype for the game and stir interest that is all. Fellas like Jim Mc playing mind games as usual."]Why are you chatting about a game in Semple 17 years ago? Kerry don't even play there what does it have to do with anything? Some amount of rubbish in that post. joeteor (Donegal) - Posts: 214 - 11/07/2018 18:42:55 2120798 Link 2 |
|
Sure luck Muck. Move us out of CP and they'll use the money excuse. Make us paupers and they'll use the population excuse. This is a great Dublin team. Look at our away record. The people who know their stuff with no axe to grind will determine their legacy, not a wannabe sports hack whose own team's record at home against this Dublin team was ???? It's 15 v 15 afterall.
Joxer (Dublin) - Posts: 4700 - 11/07/2018 18:51:43 2120800 Link 0 |
|
2014 still cuts deep I see
joeteor (Donegal) - Posts: 214 - 11/07/2018 19:04:44 2120804 Link 1 |
|
Most of the Dublin team weren't even shaving the last time Dublin played a championship game in Parnell park. Would they know where it even is? Donegalman (None) - Posts: 3830 - 11/07/2018 19:04:44 2120805 Link 1 |