HoganStand GAA Football and Hurling

Meath Forum

Division 2 2018

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

You need to Login to Post

Replying To pauk123: "Couldn't agree more a very over the top response to the suggestion that two players, who are showing excellent form at the moment, maybe should be considered if they keep that form up. Perhaps they should take Donal Lenihan as inspiration. Donal looked nothing like a county footballer when he first broke into the panel but by virtue of his consistently excellent play at club level he was given more chances and eventually clicked for him. Now he's a mainstay. I personally believe that he was helped by the club he plays for but I suppose if you are from a bigger town you have more of a constituency pulling for you." I dont see how it was an over the top response, I said Paddy has played outfield for Meath and didn't seem up to standard (1point from play in 4 games from Full forward) and Mickey Newman over the last 3 years hasn't seemed up to the pace of the Intercounty game since his injury, but if continued to play well for his club could hopefully rediscover his form of 2013 (all star nomination year) and I would happily eat my words, however I just don't see it happening myself. Both are opinions of mine based on the stats. Its not a personal jibe at either player or where they are from. A players club has no bearing for me on their ability to play outfield for the county if I think they are up to the standard, playing well in 2-1 league games at this time of the year for me isn't enough, it needs to be done in championship and on a continuous basis as Lenihan did with Dunboyne before being called up to the panel, thats all I said. ratlag (Meath) - Posts: 557 - 13/02/2018 22:36:01 2076661 Link
Replying To bert09: "Could Brian conlon do a job at half forward?" He could maybe, but you would make a weak half back line weaker. browncows (Meath) - Posts: 2342 - 13/02/2018 23:18:26 2076664 Link
Replying To JD1677: "Where I enjoy reading the different views,every now and then I feel I need to post and suggest you just keep it to the football lads!!The whereabouts of any club in the county is irrelevant ,we are all looking for the same end result!!No other county forum engages in this rubbish!" Exactly what I am trying to argue LeitrimRoyal99 (Meath) - Posts: 1458 - 13/02/2018 23:41:38 2076666 Link
Replying To royaldunne: "Still managed to beat Monaghan last year and reach Ulster final. Even your beloved Kildare couldn't beat Monaghan, and you were one bigging up Roscommon who were beat by???? Oh yeah Down." Explain two things to me 1. How are Kildare my 'beloved' county and back up your answer with proof and 'facts'. 2. When did I ever 'big up' up the Rossies? Show me the 'facts' where I supposedly did. I shall wait patiently and with great anticipation for your response. RoylerKing (Meath) - Posts: 809 - 13/02/2018 23:49:39 2076667 Link
Replying To ratlag: "I dont see how it was an over the top response, I said Paddy has played outfield for Meath and didn't seem up to standard (1point from play in 4 games from Full forward) and Mickey Newman over the last 3 years hasn't seemed up to the pace of the Intercounty game since his injury, but if continued to play well for his club could hopefully rediscover his form of 2013 (all star nomination year) and I would happily eat my words, however I just don't see it happening myself. Both are opinions of mine based on the stats. Its not a personal jibe at either player or where they are from. A players club has no bearing for me on their ability to play outfield for the county if I think they are up to the standard, playing well in 2-1 league games at this time of the year for me isn't enough, it needs to be done in championship and on a continuous basis as Lenihan did with Dunboyne before being called up to the panel, thats all I said." I wasn't referencing your response. I agree form needs to be continued into the Championship, which I said. I'm not sure cherry picking stats from 5 years ago proves much. I would expect when it's pointed out that a lad is showing great form and if he keeps it up he should be considered for the county panel, if he's interested, most people would say fair enough. Not on the Meath forum apparently it's met with fire and fury like the world has never seen, to continue your Trump theam! pauk123 (USA) - Posts: 189 - 14/02/2018 01:56:14 2076671 Link
Replying To ratlag: "I dont see how it was an over the top response, I said Paddy has played outfield for Meath and didn't seem up to standard (1point from play in 4 games from Full forward) and Mickey Newman over the last 3 years hasn't seemed up to the pace of the Intercounty game since his injury, but if continued to play well for his club could hopefully rediscover his form of 2013 (all star nomination year) and I would happily eat my words, however I just don't see it happening myself. Both are opinions of mine based on the stats. Its not a personal jibe at either player or where they are from. A players club has no bearing for me on their ability to play outfield for the county if I think they are up to the standard, playing well in 2-1 league games at this time of the year for me isn't enough, it needs to be done in championship and on a continuous basis as Lenihan did with Dunboyne before being called up to the panel, thats all I said." i would certainly love to see Newman back in the fold. He is a top class operator and a real eye for goal. A natural forward and dont forget an excellent free taker which we dont have at the moment. Maybe some time away from the fold would help and i would not like to see him disappear. We always looked a more dangerous team with him there. Injuries and lack of form have not helped him but he is one we cant forget. Also physically he has some of what we need. However i feel it will be his decision and it depends on how he applies himself now. pretender (Meath) - Posts: 358 - 14/02/2018 08:00:38 2076679 Link
When the last time we beat Cavan ? i think our recent record against has been poor to say the least. bobkarlgees (Meath) - Posts: 1263 - 14/02/2018 08:06:43 2076681 Link
Replying To browncows: "He could maybe, but you would make a weak half back line weaker." Course he could he's a great athlete and footballer but think he is perfect for half back!! Think it would be crazy to move him ! grahamc9897 (Meath) - Posts: 1174 - 14/02/2018 09:30:12 2076692 Link
Replying To pauk123: "I wasn't referencing your response. I agree form needs to be continued into the Championship, which I said. I'm not sure cherry picking stats from 5 years ago proves much. I would expect when it's pointed out that a lad is showing great form and if he keeps it up he should be considered for the county panel, if he's interested, most people would say fair enough. Not on the Meath forum apparently it's met with fire and fury like the world has never seen, to continue your Trump theam!" Again, you're making it seem like your innocent of merely suggesting POR gets a run again...it was the comment on the clubs against the Dublin border that set some people off (including myself tbh). As for the Trump theme, I think the point that poster was trying to make is that you appear to be insinuating that newcomers to the county are not real Meath supporters or entitled to opinions of players regarding making the county team. As if newcomers are second class citizens that dare not question those living here longer. Certainly an interesting simile but now that I think of it, quite apt!! Only had a brief gander at other counties forums, but from what I seen on them it would also only be on the Meath forum that you'd have someone as hostile as you towards people from clubs in a certain region of the county or people who are new to the county. "Talk about finding it hard to take a post seriously...maybe like much of Ratoath you only arrived in the county recently, in which case, I apologise as you might not remember these lads playing for Meath" I mean it's clear from that quote alone that you're the one who stoked all the tension here. I've gone way off topic but just wanted to get that off my chest. Anyway, hope we can put one over Cavan, but they always seem to up it against Meath. I remember them knocking us out of the championship in one of Boylan's last years in charge, still rankles with me! An Mhí abú dunbainneman (Meath) - Posts: 36 - 14/02/2018 09:42:14 2076696 Link
Replying To dunbainneman: "Again, you're making it seem like your innocent of merely suggesting POR gets a run again...it was the comment on the clubs against the Dublin border that set some people off (including myself tbh). As for the Trump theme, I think the point that poster was trying to make is that you appear to be insinuating that newcomers to the county are not real Meath supporters or entitled to opinions of players regarding making the county team. As if newcomers are second class citizens that dare not question those living here longer. Certainly an interesting simile but now that I think of it, quite apt!! Only had a brief gander at other counties forums, but from what I seen on them it would also only be on the Meath forum that you'd have someone as hostile as you towards people from clubs in a certain region of the county or people who are new to the county. "Talk about finding it hard to take a post seriously...maybe like much of Ratoath you only arrived in the county recently, in which case, I apologise as you might not remember these lads playing for Meath" I mean it's clear from that quote alone that you're the one who stoked all the tension here. I've gone way off topic but just wanted to get that off my chest. Anyway, hope we can put one over Cavan, but they always seem to up it against Meath. I remember them knocking us out of the championship in one of Boylan's last years in charge, still rankles with me! An Mhí abú" Apologies Paul, I think I meant that post in relation to Crinigan as opposed to yourself. dunbainneman (Meath) - Posts: 36 - 14/02/2018 09:48:48 2076700 Link
There is a big difference between facts and stats! Stats are flexible and can (and is) used to validate a point. Now about supporters-most people know that people bordering their own county are always going to very strong supporters. Now to say that you hate this county or that county is just plain stupid and every county has their quota of morons who shout abuse. browncows (Meath) - Posts: 2342 - 14/02/2018 10:48:25 2076714 Link
Replying To pretender: "i would certainly love to see Newman back in the fold. He is a top class operator and a real eye for goal. A natural forward and dont forget an excellent free taker which we dont have at the moment. Maybe some time away from the fold would help and i would not like to see him disappear. We always looked a more dangerous team with him there. Injuries and lack of form have not helped him but he is one we cant forget. Also physically he has some of what we need. However i feel it will be his decision and it depends on how he applies himself now." Would love Newman back, but his free scoring had dramatically declined since his first year. And mckeever lenihane Tobin Brennan would all be more reliable free takers than Newman at the moment royaldunne (Meath) - Posts: 19449 - 14/02/2018 14:19:09 2076808 Link
Replying To Loyalroyal17: "Cheers Ollie!" No probs at all Loyalroyal. OLLIE (Louth) - Posts: 12224 - 14/02/2018 16:11:12 2076848 Link
Lads, the poster in question has had a problem with Ratoath going back years. I'd pay no attention to them. Ratoath Royal (Meath) - Posts: 1362 - 14/02/2018 19:39:33 2076896 Link
I have said this before and I will say it again, I don't care if a lad is from rathoath, Ashbourne oldacstle , bettystown ballinabrackey, Meath hill Kells (think I have most the outer regions covered there) when they put on the green and gold they are all the same. Meath players. That is all. royaldunne (Meath) - Posts: 19449 - 14/02/2018 20:09:46 2076903 Link
Replying To royaldunne: "I have said this before and I will say it again, I don't care if a lad is from rathoath, Ashbourne oldacstle , bettystown ballinabrackey, Meath hill Kells (think I have most the outer regions covered there) when they put on the green and gold they are all the same. Meath players. That is all." Well clearly.. Why would anyone say anything different?? grahamc9897 (Meath) - Posts: 1174 - 14/02/2018 21:00:07 2076913 Link
Replying To royaldunne: "I have said this before and I will say it again, I don't care if a lad is from rathoath, Ashbourne oldacstle , bettystown ballinabrackey, Meath hill Kells (think I have most the outer regions covered there) when they put on the green and gold they are all the same. Meath players. That is all." More or less agree except the Laytown/Bettystown area. They can go to Dublin, Louth or anyone else who'll have them!! pauk123 (USA) - Posts: 189 - 15/02/2018 02:27:48 2076962 Link
This thread was for Division 2 of the Football League. It was to discuss other results and team news within the Division as we usually have a thread for each Meath game. How has it become hijacked beyond recognition? Keep it to topic at least lads. Royalio11 (Meath) - Posts: 757 - 15/02/2018 08:42:27 2076975 Link
Replying To pauk123: "More or less agree except the Laytown/Bettystown area. They can go to Dublin, Louth or anyone else who'll have them!!" Haha no graham Reilly or Ben Brennan, or rob O'Malley or Bernard Flynn. ? royaldunne (Meath) - Posts: 19449 - 15/02/2018 09:51:22 2076989 Link
Just to finish the whole pot thing, he has made it absolutely clear he has no interest in playing again for Meath. royaldunne (Meath) - Posts: 19449 - 15/02/2018 20:25:41 2077238 Link